Peyton Manning's future is up in the air with the Colts. There is no guarantee that he will ever play again as he has reportedly had four surgeries on his neck in the past year. However, that won't stop teams from scrambling to add the soon-to-be thirty-six year-old future Hall of Famer. One of those teams that might show interest is the New York Jets. Jets players have come out publicly in support of the team getting Peyton but does this move make sense for the Jets?
It isn't every day that you see a franchise quarterback hit the open market. It just doesn't happen. Now, there is no certainty right now that Peyton will hit the open market but it is unlikely the Colts will roll the dice on a $28 million question mark if Peyton doesn't look like he can play football. If he can play, it makes no sense for the Colts to cut their quarterback, regardless of the squabbles Peyton and owner Jim Irsay have had. But, since this is a speculative piece designed around Peyton ending up on the Jets I will leave the Colts out of this. Let's just assume the Colts let Peyton go and the Jets are interested.
The Jets locker room this year was closer to a circus than it was a football team coming off of back-to-back AFC Championship game appearances. There is, or was, a good football team in there somewhere. Did it just break apart overnight? I don't think so. However, that isn't to say there aren't big holes on the Jets that need to be filled. One of those holes is not at the quarterback position.
Mark Sanchez has been frustrating, especially to Jets fans. They expected a franchise quarterback to begin to emerge this season. After all, he did help lead the team to back-to-back AFC Championship game appearances. Bad quarterbacks really can't do that. The problem with the Jets is their personnel decisions. They reach for aging veterans to plug into the holes created by years worth of poor drafting. Going into this season, the Jets had Santonio Holmes flanked by Plaxico Burress, who hadn't played football since 2008 when his career was interrupted by a nightclub, sweatpants, and a handgun. He went to jail and yet here he was, expected to be the team's number two wide receiver for all intents and purposes. Derrick Mason was brought in to be the slot/possession guy but Mason was thirty-seven years old. Mason was so ineffective that he was traded on October 11th after openly complaining. Mark Sanchez has not been given the tools to succeed.
Bringing in a quarterback who is nearing the end of his career is not the answer. Sure, Peyton is a great quarterback, a first ballot Hall of Famer but giving up on a supposed franchise quarterback after three years of starting reeks of stupidity. If the Jets go out and get Peyton they might have one or two years of good football. We've seen Peyton, when healthy, elevate a mediocre football team. However, what happens in two years when Peyton is now thirty-eight? Do they use another draft pick on a quarterback and have Peyton tutor him? What if the Jets sign Peyton and cut or trade Sanchez and Peyton get hurt in the fourth game of the season? Do they implode the whole football team and hope to start over? They would basically have to. They would be in the Colts position right now.
If I were Mike Tannenbaum, I would keep Sanchez and clean the locker room up. Trade malcontents, even if it means trading Santonio Holmes. There are going to be enough good wide receivers coming into free agency that Holmes can be replaced. The Jets could also use some offensive linemen that can block the speed rushers that are now predominant on defensive lines everywhere. Wayne Hunter was terrible on the right side and finding a right tackle who is good, not great but just good enough, is a lot easier than finding a quarterback in the draft. Sanchez hasn't been terrible. Sure, he has been at times, but so have a lot of quarterbacks, even Peyton Manning, Eli Manning, Tony Romo, and Philip Rivers to name a few. These are excellent quarterbacks. Instead of throwing their quarterback under the bus, the Jets should do what the Giants did for Eli, get rid of malcontents that hinder the quarterbacks growth. The Giants got rid of Jeremy Shockey, a pest by all accounts who pestered Eli in the huddle to throw him the football. Once Shockey got injured and was no longer in the huddle the Giants went on to win a Super Bowl and ever since Eli has gotten better and better with a few bumps in the road. If Santonio Holmes is degrading the man throwing him the football then Holmes has to go. Wide receivers can be found, franchise quarterbacks can't.
If the Jets management really believes that Mark Sanchez is not the answer then they had better draft a quarterback and develop him, especially if they are going after Peyton if he becomes available. This year's quarterback crop, at least in projected elite quarterbacks, is short. Still, a Brandon Weeden, an older quarterback a la Chris Weinke, will be available when the Jets pick in a middle round. If not, there should be someone who can at least compete for a spot. Is Greg McElroy the answer? Unknown but doubtful. Obtaining Peyton's services will surely mean a capable backup will be necessary, just in case. We all know the Jets are built to compete now. They are aging, and in some spots aging poorly. They don't have a legitimate pass rush and rely on schemes to get to the quarterback or defend against the pass. Opposing quarterbacks have all the time in the world to throw and that will lead to someone getting open. Sure, the Jets have Darrelle Revis but unless they clone him the chances are that one of the opposing team's wide receivers will get open against Antonio Cromartie or Kyle Wilson.
The Jets problems didn't stem from the quarterback position. Yes, Sanchez threw untimely interceptions and fumbled at inopportune moments. However, his ground game was putrid to start the year. Shonn Greene did eventually emerge as a 1,000 yard rusher but his inability early in the year to get major chunks of yardage compounded the Jets offensive woes, especially when two of the teams top three receivers were over thirty-four years-old and one hadn't played football in three years. Despite all of the Jets offensive problems, Sanchez improved on his completion percentage (56.7, up from 54.8 in 2010) and threw 26 touchdowns, up from 17 the year before. His yards gained per completion were the lowest they had been since he came into the NFL at 11.3, further testimony of the Jets older receiving corps.
Mark Sanchez has talent. Will he be what Peyton Manning was in his prime? Probably not, in fact I'd bet on it. Few quarterbacks can ever hope to be. Eli Manning isn't as good as his brother and yet has more Super Bowl rings than Peyton. Winning Super Bowls is not just a quarterback thing. Even Peyton in his prime would have a hard time winning a Super Bowl with the Jets and their current roster. There is no Dwight Freeney of Robert Mathis to get to the opposing team's QB. There is no Marvin Harrison or Reggie Wayne. Holmes has talent but he also has what appears to be an attitude problem. There are much bigger problems on the Jets than their quarterback. They need a pass rush. They need a right tackle. They need a younger, more capable back than LaDainian Tomlinson to share some duties with Shonn Greene. They have an emerging tight end in Dustin Keller. They have a left tackle in D'Brickashaw Ferguson. They have a center in Nick Mangold. They have the shut-down corner in Revis. Their linebacking corps is aging but very good. They need some safety help. They need young wide receivers that can stretch the field with their speed, something the Jets really didn't have. The Jets don't need a quarterback, especially a thirty-six year old one who is not a sure thing to stay healthy. If Mike Tannenbaum thinks this is the route the Jets should go down then perhaps Woody Johnson should go another route in the general manager department. Obtaining Peyton Manning might...might help the Jets for a year or two but he could also set them back five years, something I don't think Jets fans can tolerate.
Friday, February 17, 2012
Wednesday, February 15, 2012
Cashman and his Pitchers
With the A.J. Burnett saga looking like it is coming to an end, I wanted to take a look at the free agents pitchers signed, and the trades Cashman has made for pitchers since becoming GM of the Yankees in 1998. I will start in 1998 and do a year by year trade and free agent signing review. This is for pitchers only. Here goes:
1998:
- Signed Orlando Hernandez as an amateur free agent. This move gets an A+. El Duque was one of the Yankees best starters in the postseason. There were few pitchers in baseball anyone trusted more with a game on the line.
- There wasn't much else to do to this team. The core was still together and the Yankees would roll to baseball's best record and eventually a World Series title.
1999:
- Brian Cashman had a bit of a problem. Scott Brosius was a clutch player, a good defensive third baseman, and fit in well with the Yankee scheme. The Yankees had a super third base prospect in Mike Lowell and had just drafted another third base phenom in the 1998 draft in Drew Henson. Cashman's solution was to trade the ready for the big league Mike Lowell to the Marlins for Ed Yarnall, Todd Noel, and Mark Johnson, three minor league pitchers. Yarnall at one time was considered one of the best left-handed pitching prospects in the game. Lowell would go on to win World Series titles with the Marlins and Red Sox and make 3 All-Star game appearances, and won a Gold Glove. For his career he managed to drive in 952 runs over 13 seasons, hit 223 home runs and produce an OPS (on base plus slugging percentage) of .805 for his career. Cashman's first major trade was a terrible one. Yarnall flamed out and would be traded to the Reds. Noel made a couple of relief appearances and would be gone. Johnson never made the Yankees.
- The second major trade for Brian Cashman was a blockbuster. He traded Homer Bush, Graeme Lloyd, and David Wells to the Blue Jays for Roger Clemens. This trade gets an A+ as Clemens helped lead the Yankees to two more World Series titles and won a Cy Young. I'm not getting into performance enhancing drugs here, you make your own call. David Wells, as we will see later would come back to the Yankees.
- The third trade of the year for Cashman came after the 1999 season, on December 22nd. He shipped Hideki Irabu off to the Montreal Expos for Jake Westbrook, Ted Lilly, and Christian Parker. Westbrook and Lilly would end up becoming reliable starters, both still pitching to this day. Unfortnately, neither of them did it with the Yankees for very long. Parker made one start for the Yankees and that was it. Westbrook and Lilly were two useable pitchers and Irabu had worn out his welcome in the Bronx. Good trade by Cashman.
2000:
- It was a minor move at the time but Cashman signed Chien Ming Wang to an amateur free agent contract. It would be a few years before people realized who Wang was but he would go on to win 19 games twice for the Yankees.
- Jake Westbrook didn't last long as a Yankee. He was shipped to the Indians with Zach Day, and Ricky Ledee in exchange for David Justice in June. Justice did help the Yankees limp into the playoffs and go on to win the 2000 World Series. Westbrook would go on to win 44 games between 2004 and 2006.
- The other mid-season trade occurred on July 12th when the Yankees acquired Denny Neagle from the Reds in exchange for Jackson Meilan, Drew Henson, Brian Reith, and Ed Yarnall. Neagle was supposed to stabilize a rotation that suddenly wasn't getting the job done. David Cone wasn't the same since his perfect game against the Expos. Neagle didn't do anything to help and the Yankees faded down the stretch and were lucky to make the playoffs. He would be allowed to leave as a free agent at the end of the season. However, none of the guys Cashman gave up made an impact in the big leagues. Henson was reacquired for Wily Mo Pena just before the start of the 2001 season.
- In December, Cashman signed Mike Mussina. Mussina would be the second best free agent singing Cashman has made behind C.C. Sabathia. There isn't much else to say about Moose, he was a good one.
2001:
- The first major pitching move, if you could call it that, was the acquisition of Enrique Wilson, a utility infielder in exchange for Damaso Marte. Marte will sound familiar to Yankee fans because in 2008, the Yankees acquired him from the Pirates to help fill the left-handed specialist role out of the bullpen. I don't know what Cashman was thinking. A hard-throwing lefty for a utility infielder who hit .216 as a Yankee. But hey, someone had to replace Luis Sojo, right? Yep, great move, or not.
- In June, the Yankees began to look for bullpen help. Jeff Nelson, the reliable set-up man, was gone. So, the Yankees shipped D'Angelo Jimenez to the Padres for reliever Jay Witasick. Witasick was not good but not awful but never earned Joe Torre's trust which might have saved his arm some major surgeries. Witasick would be traded at the end of the year to the Giants for John Van Der Wal, a spare outfielder and pinch-hitter.
- On July 1st, Cashman was on the troll again for relief help, trying to replace that Jeff Nelson fellow. This time he sent minor-leaguer Ricardo Aromboles to the Reds (there was a lot of trades with the Reds during this stretch wasn't there?) in exchange for Mark Wohlers, the former Braves closer mostly famous for giving up the game-tying home run to Jim Leyritz in the 1996 World Series. Wohlers wasn't very good. Not at all. Needless to say, Wohlers didn't win the set-up man role.
- On July 4th, the Yankees gave reliever Brian Boehringer his independence from the team and sent him to the Giants for backup catcher Bobby Estalella and minor leaguer Joe Smith. Boehringer pitched pretty well with the Yankees but I guess not good enough.
- On July 30th, the Yankees acquired a friendly face as they received Sterling Hitchcock from the Padres in exchange for Darren Blakely and Brett Jodie. Hitchcock was not very good as either a starter or reliever. But, the Yankees didn't give anything up to get him so you can't blame Cashman for rolling the dice on a guy who knew the Yankee clubhouse.
- After the season, the Yankees looked to the free agent market to fill the void left by Jeff Nelson's departure. They had to look somewhere since the trades Cashman made didn't work out. The first free agent reliever the Yankees gave a big contract to was Steve Karsay. Karsay wasn't bad. He was just never healthy. The Yankees spent $21 million for four years of a mostly injured Steve Karsay. He only appeared in 91 games, 78 of which came in his first year as a Yankee after only appearing in 31 the year before with the Indians. Thank you Joe Torre!
2002:
- Cashman kicked off the year by signing old friend David Wells as a free agent. Wells would go on to win 34 games for the Yankees over the next two years, the exact same number of wins he had in his first 2-year stint with the Yankees. This was a good move by Cashman.
- On July 5th, Cashman made one of the worst trades he has ever made. It was a three team deal that saw the Yankees send Ted Lilly, Jason Arnold, and John-Ford Griffin to the A's. The Yankees received Jeff Weaver from the Tigers. Weaver was a former first pick and never got into a groove on some awful Tigers teams. Lilly was being used as a spot-starter on the Yankees, never getting much of a chance except when there was an injury to one of the starters. Lilly would go on to win 115 games for the A's, Blue Jays, Cubs, and Dodgers. Weaver is out of baseball. Weaver was absolutely terrible as a Yankee, he went 12-12 with a 5.35 ERA, a 1.49 WHIP, and was even worse in the playoffs. Bad move. Lilly was, and has been a much better pitcher over the last decade than Weaver was over his entire career.
- After the 2002 season the Yankees began gearing up for 2003. In December, they signed Chris Hammond, a lefty reliever coming off of a monster year with the Braves. Hammond posted a 0.95 ERA and went 7-2 out of the bullpen for the Braves. Cashman was still trying to find the guy to set up for Mariano Rivera and Hammond was another roll of the dice, a pitcher coming off a career year. Hammond wasn't awful in Pinstripes, not by a long shot. He appeared in 62 games in 2003, posted a 3-2 mark with a 2.86 ERA and 1.20 WHIP. Steady numbers. He was traded following the 2003 season as we will see later.
2003:
- Cashman started the year by shipping Orlando Hernandez to the White Sox in exchange for middle reliever Antonio Osuna and a minor leaguer whose mother never knew he played baseball, Delvis Lantigua. The White Sox flipped El Duque and some minor leaguers/fringe major leaguers a few days later to the Expos for Bartolo Colon, who was acquired by then-Expos GM Omar Minaya in exchange for Cliff Lee, Grady Sizemore, and Brandon Phillips the year before. El Duque never pitched for the Expos due to injury. I guess getting Osuna, who at least pitched that year in exchange for someone who didn't pitch at all is a win.
- Another middle reliever was signed, this time it was Juan Acevedo. Acevedo was coming off of a career year with the Tigers and Cashman hoped he could maybe step in as a dependable reliever. Yeah, that didn't happen and Acevedo was released in June and was out of baseball by the next year.
- In February, Cashman signed Jon Lieber to a two-year contract. Leiber was a former 20 game winner with the Cubs but had just undergone Tommy John surgery. The first year Leiber rehabbed his arm. The second year, 2004, Leiber would become arguably the best Yankee pitcher down the stretch. A risky but smart move by Cashman.
- Two days later, Cashman swooped in and stole Jose Contreras out from under the Red Sox nose and signed the Cuban star as a free agent. Contreras was supposed to be Luis Tiant reincarnated. Well, he wasn't. He is still pitching as a reliever and is fairly decent but the Yankees got little to return on Contreras except the "Evil Empire" moniker that Red Sox President Larry Lucchino placed up the Yankees.
- The search for quality relief led Cashman to swing another trade in July, this time acquiring Armando Benitez from the Mets in exchange for Jason Anderson, and two other minor leaguers whose mothers didn't even know they played baseball. Benitez is the rare guy who actually pitched worse than his 1-1 record and 1.93 ERA as evidenced by his 1.50 WHIP. He blew a game against the Red Sox and that led the "can't handle the big game" label to be placed squarely on Armando's back. He would have one more season, as the Marlins closer, that was good before imploding faster than a sinking Russian nuclear sub. We will soon find out Mr. Benitez's fate with the Yankees. Here's a hint, he only pitched in 9 games for them.
- Cashman continued to look for bullpen help, this time getting Jesse Orosco from the Padres. Orosco was 46 years-old at the time and was expected to be the lefty-specialist the Yankees needed. Well, it didn't work out and Orosco called it a career after getting dealt to the Twins. He did put up some interesting numbers as a Yankee though. They include a 10.38 ERA, 4.1 innings across 15 games, and a WHIP of 2.308. I seriously might have been able to do just as bad, maybe even better.
- With Orosco not working out, Cashman swung another deal with the Reds, this time getting Gabe White as part of a conditional deal. White wasn't the answer either but since nothing big was given up for White Cashman gets a pass on this deal. It was just another transaction in a long line of transactions for middle relievers that never seemed to work out.
- At the trade deadline, Cashman traded a fading Robin Ventura to the Dodgers for outfielder Bubba Crosby and reliever Scott Proctor. It would be a little while for Proctor to make his Yankees debut and his arm would never be the same as Joe Torre trusted him and rode Proctor into the ground, literally ruining his career and blowing out his arm. At the time, this seemed like a good trade. Ventura was a shell of his former self and the Yankees had Aaron Boone coming in from the Reds. Proctor, at time, seemed like he might be the guy who could bridge the gap from starters to Mariano. Then Joe Torre happened.
- In August of 2003, the Yankees had tired of Armando Benitez and shipped him to the Mariners for Jeff Nelson. The Yankees had been trying to find a replacement for Nelson ever since Nelson left. They didn't want to pay Nelson a crazy amount of money and instead wound up spending more on guys who couldn't replace him. The sad thing was, Nelson was not the Jeff Nelson the Yankees remembered and he would be gone at the end of the year and the quest to find a replacement for Jeff Nelson continued.
- In December of 2003, only a couple of months after the Yankees lost the World Series to the Marlins, Cashman found himself trying to replace 3/5ths of his starting rotation. Andy Pettitte signed with the Astros. Roger Clemens retired and then unretired and signed with the Astros. David Wells was allowed to leave as a free agent as he was getting old and his chronic medical problems made him a little too risky going forward. Enter Kevin Brown. Brown was coming off an excellent year with the Dodgers and the Yankees needed pitchers. Brown was, at the time, signed to a ridiculous contract and the Yankees had money to burn. They shipped Yhency Brazoban, failure Jeff Weaver, and Brandon Weeden (who is now hoping to be drafted in the NFL after being a fairly successful QB in college this past season) to the Dodgers for Brown. The problem was Brown was 39 years old when he pitched for the Yankees, made a ton of money, and was now expected to jump alongside Mike Mussina as the teams new 1-2 punch. Well, it didn't work out that way and Yankee fans remember Brown as one of the reasons the Red Sox did what they did in 2004 and also for punching a wall with his hand and missing several starts because of it. Failure.
- Three days after getting Brown, the Yankees addressed their rotation again, obtaining Javier Vazquez from the Expos in exchange for Nick Johnson, Randy Choate, and Juan Rivera. Vazquez was supposed to be the new Pedro Martinez, a good pitcher in Montreal being held back by a terrible team. Vazquez would make the 2004 All-Star team because he did pitch well the first half of the season and it looked like the Yankees had a new, young, stud pitcher going forward. Then the second-half collapse came and Javier's ERA exploded. He wasn't much better in the playoffs, in fact he was worse. The Yankees cut ties with Javy after the season.
- The day after the Yankees got Javy, they signed Paul Quantrill, another reliever they hoped would carry the success from the previous year's career year into the Yankee bullpen. Quantrill was a proven workhorse, someone Joe Torre could ride forever. He led the league in appearances the previous three years and was fairly successful. One of those seasons was even in the American League East with the Blue Jays. Well, Quantrill would be ridden hard by Joe Torre in 2004, even if he wasn't very effective. He led the league once again in appearances with 86! However, he was a mid-thirties pitcher with a million miles on his arm and Cashman still gave him $3 million per year. Ugggh!
- Chris Hammond was shipped away to the A's for two minor leaguers that never helped the Yankees at all. Granted, Hammond was 37 going on 38 when the Yankees traded him but he had shown he could be fairly successful out of the bullpen. He had a couple of decent years left in him before retiring. Eh, whatever, right?
- On December 16th, the Yankees thought they found the answer to their set-up man question. Tom Gordon was signed to be that guy. He was good but not great. In 2004, he was very good, then hit a bit of wall in the playoffs, probably from being abused by Joe Torre. He was abused once again in 2005, appearing in 79 games after getting into 80 games in 2004. At 38 years-old, the Yankees figured they used up all of the good Tom Gordon and let him walk via free agency after 2005.
2004:
- The year started off kind of slow pitching wise. The Yankees had made their big splashes at the end of 2003 to get ready for the 2004 season. They would trade Alfonso Soriano for Alex Rodriguez. Bring in the washed-up Donovan Osborne and actually allow him to pitch big league innings.
- Orlando Hernandez was brought back and he pitched fairly well between injuries.
- In May, the Yankees made a minor deal that sent a minor leaguer to the Dodgers and received Tanyon Sturtze. Poor Sturtze would become trusted by Joe Torre who developed weird relationships with relievers that he trusted, even if they weren't the best out there. He would then ride those men into the ground out of fear of giving the ball to someone else. I think Torre suffered from PTSD after Nelson and Mike Stanton left.
- Gabe White was sent back to the Reds in June for Charlie Manning and cash. Manning was one of the pitching prospects the Yankees sent to the Reds in one of their 4,000 deals over the last couple of years.
- In July, the Yankees signed amateur free agent Ivan Nova. Looking good so far.
- At the July 31st trading deadline, the Yankees sent Jose Contreras packing, finally having seen enough of him. He was sent to the White Sox for Esteban Loaiza who miraculously won 21 games the year before with the White Sox and then imploded. Loaiza is gone from baseball. Contreras is still pitching out of the bullpen.
- In December, after the Red Sox bounced the patched together Yankees from the ALCS, Cashman went out and brought in Mike Stanton, who was another reliever Joe Torre couldn't live without in exchange for Felix Heredia. Stanton had been on the Mets the previous two years and was now a 38 year-old relief pitcher. Well, Stanton was awful and would be released after appearing in just 28 games with the 2005 Yankees. Bringing Jeff Nelson back to replace Jeff Nelson didn't work and bringing Mike Stanton back rto replace Mike Stanton didn't work.
- To help bolster the bullpen, (see a theme here with a lot of these trades and signings?) the Yankees shipped a disgruntled Kenny Lofton to the Phillies for a hard-throwing reliever named Felix Rodriguez. F-Rod was only 32 years-old and had been one of the better relievers over the last few seasons...in the National League. Needless to say, Rodriguez didn't last with the Yankees and was allowed to walk as a free agent after the 2005 season.
- Kevin Brown, and Javier Vazquez weren't working out for the Yankees. Esteban Loaiza didn't work out. Jon Leiber was a free agent. The Yankees once again needed pitching help. In December of 2004, the Yankees tried to bring in pitchers that would prevent the Red Sox from embarrassing them in the playoffs ever again. Enter Carl Pavano and Jaret Wright. Pavano was signed on Dec. 20th and Wright was signed Dec. 28th. Pavano was given a 4-year contract worth over $40 million. Jaret Wright, coming off that career year in the National League was given $21 over 3 years. Well, Pavano made 26 starts for the Yankees...over the entire length of the contract. He missed all of 2006 and never made more than 17 starts in a season. Of course, I forgot to mention Carl Pavano was also coming off a career year in the NAtional League and the Yankees remembered him from the 2003 World Series. There is nothing else that needs to be said...go up to a Yankee fan and mention Carl Pavano and their reaction will tell you all you need to know.
- Jaret Wright was the other big free agent signing that was supposed to remake the Yankees rotation. He was a power pitcher and...well he wasn't the same pitcher that dominated Yankee bats in the 1997 AL Playoffs that's for sure. I don't know what the Yankees were thinking giving Jaret Wright that contract.
2005:
- Javy Vazquez was considered a failure after one season in the Bronx. The Yankees needed dominant pitching. Enter Randy Johnson. The Big Unit was acquired from the Dimaondbacks in exchange for Javy, Brad Halsey, and Dioner Navarro. Randy Johnson was coming off a year where he struck out 290 batters to lead the Majors. George Steinbrenner had a thing for Johnson ever since he was a Mariner. Of course, he was past 40 when the Yankees acquired him and he pitched better than most 40 year-olds probably could. He won 34 games as a Yankee over 2 seasons. His first season in Pinstripes was pretty good, winning 17 games and posting a 3.79 ERA and piling up 211 strikeouts. But, Randy was a cantankerous soul and would be gone from the Yankees after only two year. Javier Vazquez has actually outpitched Randy Johnson since the trade and is 10 years younger. But, hey, mess up once with the Yankees and you gotta get packing.
- In February, the Yankees brought back Ramiro Mendoza. He was another former Yankee bullpen arm that they always had trouble replacing. Like Jeff Nelson and Mike Stanton before him, Mendoza's second time with the Yankees was forgettable. He appeared in 1 game and was gone from baseball.
- Speaking of returns, Brian Boehringer was signed on July 1st, his third go around with the Yankees. When in doubt bring in a familiar face, eh Brian? Less than a month later he was released without ever appearing in a game.
- Paul Quantrill, the used up middle reliever, was used as trade bait to help out the Yankee rotation which was injury plagued to say the least. Come on, Jaret Wright and Carl Pavano people. Kevin Brown who last played with Ty Cobb, and Randy Johnson who George sometimes called Walter...old and beat up were the Yankees. In return for Quantrill, the Yankees receiver Darrell May and Tim Redding. They needed people to fill in as starters and they picked the two most unqualified guys to ever do that. May was a 33 year-old wannabe Major Leaguer. Redding was a little younger, 27, and both were equally horrible in Pinstripes. However, the Yankees farm system didn't have much in the way of Major League-ready arms with the exception of Chien Ming Wang and this is what they had to resort to to try and fill in some starts.
- After May and Redding flamed out, the Yankees acquired Al Letier from the Marlins as part of a conditional deal. Leiter was 39 and nearing the end of a very successful career. Sadly, he wasn't the answer either.
- Just a few days before the trading deadline, the Yankees were still looking for someone to pitch some innings from the 5th spot in the rotation. So they acquired Shawn Chacon from the Rockies for Eduardo Sierra and Ramon Ramirez. Chacon was a flash in the pan, pitching well his first year with the Yankees and stabilizing the back end of the rotation along with fellow flash in the pan Aaron Small. By the next year Chacon was awful...or normal, and he was shipped to the Pirates for Craig Wilson in 2006.
- I bet most Yankee fans don't remember how desperate they were for pitching that year. Well, they signed Hideo Nomo at one point, though he never appeared in a game for them. He was a washed-up shell of his former self.
- The bullpen was still a mish-mash and the Yankees were in need of a left-handed reliever. Sound familiar? Well enter Alan Embree, formerly of the Red Sox. Exit Alan Embree after posting a 7.53 ERA in 24 appearances spanning 14.1 innings.
- Bullpen problems? What bullpen problems? The Yankees acquired Ron Villone from the Marlins in exchange for a minor leaguer. Villone was a lefty. Maybe he could get lefty hitters out. Right?
- In December, after letting tom Gordon walk via free agency, the Yankees found hard-throwing Kyle Farnsworth sitting out there, waiting to have money thrown at him. Cashman had the money and he did the throwing, inking Farnsworth to a 3 year, $18 million contract. Farnsworth was coming off a good season that he split between Detroit and Atlanta, had never shown consistent stuff but had a lively fastball and sometimes had a nasty slider. Oh, what a Jeff Nelson he could be, Cashman probably thought to himself. He resembled the second coming of Jeff Nelson more than the first and was traded in his thrid year with the team. If he had been healthy all year long Joe Torre might have blown out his arm and saved other managers the frustration of having to put Farnsworth in the game. In all seriousness he is a nice guy and is a serviceable middle reliever, just not worth the money the Yankees threw at him with the expectations that came with it. Another middle-reliever fail.
- Then, on December 15th, the Yankees signed Mike Myers. The answer to the Mike Stanton replacement question...at the moment. Myers was a lefty, was 37 years old, and, did I mention he was a lefty? Myers was going to finally be the guy to get out David Ortiz. Myers wasn't awful but he was frustrating. He would get out a righty, face Ortiz and give up a homer. Or he would give up a base-hit to the only lefty he would face, leave the game and get ready for tomorrow's lefty hitter. He wasn't consistent and was maddening every bit as much as Boone Logan is today. Maybe more so. Middle relief fail #3,906.
2006:
- The bullpen was still up in the air...as if it had ever been settled since 2000, so the Yankees signed Octavio Dotel to a contract. Dotel, like Leiber before him, was rehabbing from surgery but it was a low-risk, potential high reward deal. Dotel pitched in 14 games for the 2006 yankees, wasn't very good and was allowed to leave as a free agent. Dotel would recover fully from his surgery and be a pretty good reliever and is still pitching today at age 37.
- Some minor pitching moves took place in January and February. Ramiro Mendoza was signed to a free agent contract. Presumably to replace himself. Darrell Rasner was claimed off of waivers from the Washington Nationals. Mendoza never appeared in a game again in baseball and Rasner would be a somewhat decent fill-in starter for the Yankees over the next couple of years before taking his talents to Asia. The Yankees also signed 38 year0old Scott Erickson to a deal. That would have been awesome if this were 1990, not 2006. Erickson was done, washed up and used. He still made it into 9 games with the Yankees before Cashman realized there were better options out there.
- On July 1st, the Yankees took a chance on the recently released Brian Bruney. Bruney had an excellent fastball and had had problems controlling that pitch. He would become a pretty good bullpen guy before losing his control again and some fastball velocity. But the bullpen is the most volatile part of any teams roster and a roll of the dice with a guy like Bruney can sometimes heap huge rewards. you don't have to spend $21 million over 4 years for a reliever.
- For some reason Cashman had a short obsession with washed-up former Orioles. First it was Scott Erickson then came Sidney Ponson. Ponson somehow managed to make 3 starts and 2 relief appearances in 2006 for the Yankees. He was released just over a month later, in August. What is even crazier is that he was brought back in 2008 as we will see later.
- On August 11th, Cashman signed John Axford to a minor league deal. Axford didn't do anything special for the Yankees but has gone on to become one of the best closers in baseball. Weird how that works sometimes, huh?
- On November 10th, tired of the Gary Sheffield act, and with Bobby Abreu now in right field, the Yankees shipped Sheff to the Tigers for three minor league pitchers, Anthony Claggett, Kevin Whelan, and Humberto Sanchez. Whelan is the only one still in the Yankees organization, but all three made appearances for the Yankees. Claggett was awful. Sanchez never recovered from the arm surgery, and Whelan is a AAA closer that has trouble finding the strike zone too often. All that for Gary Sheffield!
- On November 12th, the Yankees shipped Jaret Wright who was terrible as a starter to the Orioles for reliever Chris Britton. Britton would become somewhat famous for seemingly using up all of his options in the span of seven minutes as the Yankees shuttled him back and forth between Scranton and New York in 2007.
- On December 8th, the Yankees went all redux again, this time successfully. They brought back Andy Pettitte. I don't need to say anything more about Andy.
- On December 19th, after watching the Red Sox sign Daisuke Matsuzaka, the Yankees dipped back into the Japanese leagues. This time they came up with Kei Igawa, and gave him a 5 year deal worth $4 million a year. He made most of his money setting AA and AAA pitching records. Good for him, I guess. Igawa will forever be the ink stain on Cashman's shirt. He appeared in 16 game, 13 starts, for the Yankees, posted an ungodly ERA of 6.66 (see what I did there?) and allowed 15 homers in 71.2 innings. Yikes! The saga of Igawa is sad. the guy wanted to pitch, he never gave up, even when the Yankees offered to end the pain. He is a free agent now, and Brian Cashman can sleep at night...sort of...when stalkers aren't ringing his doorbell I guess.
2007:
- The Yankees had let the Randy Johnson experiment go on far too long. He was miserable, fans were miserable, and Cashman was miserable. On January 9th, he was dealt to the Diamondbacks for Luis Vizcaino (he might be an answer as a middle reliever, hopefully, maybe?), minor league shortstop Alberto Gonzalez, and minor league pitchers Ross Ohlendorf and Steven Jackson. All of these guys would see time with the big club. Ohlendorf, who will pop up again later, was the best of the bunch. Vizcaino followed Octavio Dotel, Tom Gordon, Kyle Farnsworth, Felix Rodriguez, etc. out of town.
- May 6th, Susan Waldman makes hysterical noises on the radio, yelling "Roger Clemens is in Gawge Steinbrennah's bawx!" a few thousand times as the Yankees dramatically announced Roger Clemens would be coming back to join Andy Pettitte back in the Bronx. Roger was later seen bench pressing the Old Yankee Stadium which would ruin the foundation of the landmark and lead the Yankees to have to build a whole new Stadium. OK, that last part isn't true.
- Bye-bye Scott Proctor. At the trading deadline, the Yankees shipped Scott Proctor off to the Dodgers in exchange for utility guy Wilson Betemit. Scott Proctor, who somehow managed to make an appearance in every Yankee game since Billy Martin was manager, was probably very glad to get away from Joe Torre who actually held Proctor hostage in the bullpen chained to a wall and fed leftover hot dogs. OK, that's not true but it sure seemed like it. Proctor would later wonder what he did to piss God off when Torre followed him out to Los Angeles a year later.
- On December 4th, the Yankees traded one of their top pitching prospects, Tyler Clippard to the Washington Nationals for reliever Jonathan Alabadejo. Clippard had a very nive MLB debut against the Mets but Cashman got impatient. Clippard is now famous for "Clipparding" wins in Washington where he actually made the All-Star team last season. He is the vulture extraordinaire, getting wins and pitching well despite not pitching well. Wish I could do that. Either way, this was a win for the Nats. Alabadejo used the Scranton Shuttle almost as often as Chris Britton.
- On December 12th, the Yankees remembered Andy Pettitte was a free agent, unlike in 2003, and they actually re-signed him! Hooray!
- On December 21st, the Yankees thought they had themselves a new bullpen arm when they inked LaTroy Hawkins to a contract worht over $3 million per year. Hawkins was coming off of a sensational year and Cashman finally thought this was the year the pitcher coming off of a career year in the NL would translate into the AL in Pinstripes. Except the story didn't end up that way. Hawkins went from having a good year with Colorado in 2007, to being God-awful for the Yankees in 2008, to being dominant for the Astros after the Yankees traded him in June for Matt Cusick. Wow, great job.
2008:
- The Yankees had been scrap-heaping arms in AAA. They signed Billy Traber (lefty!) and Heath Phillips (lefty!) to minor league deals in January. Traber made the show and showed everyone he wasn't cut out for Major League Baseball. Phillips was replacement level at AAA.
- In February, the Yankees signed a little-known Mexican Leaguer named Alfredo Aceves to a deal. Aceves would become a kind of better version of Ramiro Mendoza, spot starting and relieving and vulturing wins. alas, he had trouble staying healthy and the Yankees didn't offer him a Major League contract after the 2010 season so he went to the Red Sox for 2011, battled injuries, and filled in nicely as a starter. Oh well.
- June 19th, 2008...Welcome back Sidney Ponson! Oh, you still are terrible. Darn.
- July 11th, wow, Eric Milton is a Yankee again! The top pitching prospect that was traded for Chuck Knoblauch signs a minor league deal. He never throws a pitch for the Yankees because of injuries. Not sure if Cashman was trying to Leiber him but it didn't work.
- Three days before the non-waiver trade deadline in July, the Yankees package Jose Tabata, Ross Ohlendorf, Jeff Karstens, and Daniel McCutcheon to the Pirates in exchange for Xavier Nady and Damaso Marte. Marte was traded to the Pirates years before if you recall and the Yankees really needed that lefty reliever. Nady was that extra bat the Yankees needed to propel them into the playoffs. Only they missed the playoffs in 2008. Shucks. Karstens is somehow still pitching in Pittsburgh. Ohlendorf is now a free agent and is still fairly young (redux?). Tabata, once a top prospect, has some age issues, is married to Martha Washington's slightly younger sister, had thought about quitting baseball in 2008, and is now a decent enough outfielder for the Pirates. The Pirates win this deal because they got players who are still playing for them. Nady is gone from the Yankees. Marte had a decent World Series run in 2009, got re-signed, and hurt himself. Or maybe he robbed a bank and ran away. Who knows? Who cares?
- July 30th saw the Yankees make two trades, the LaTroy Hawkins trade with Houston and they actually found a taker for Kyle Farnsworth, sending him to the tigers in exchange for Ivan Rodriguez. Yes, Pudge Rodriguez. Same guy, different decade.
- In December of 2008, the Yankees lost Ivan Nova in the Rule 5 Draft to the San Diego Padres. Luckily for the Yankees, they returned him. Phew!
- Having just missed the playoffs, Brian Cashman and George Steinbrenner decided they were not gonna let that happen again. So the first strike in free agency was for A.J. Burnett, the very pitcher who inspired this post to begin with. Burnett had a decent year in 2009. a terrible one in 2010. And a blah, bad one in 2011. The Yankees have two years left of Burnett that they are trying to unload on someone (Pirates?) and a total of $33 million. Yikes! That contract hasn't worked out at all like the Yankees hoped. At least he wasn't Pavano or Igawa, right? Right?
- Just days after inking the inked up Burnett, Cashman landed his man, C.C. Sabathia to a monster deal. Mussina was retiring and the Yankees needed an ace. Wang was done with the Yankees, and the Yankees needed an ace. Did I mention they needed an ace? Anyway, Sabathia is Cashman's best move and his best pitching move since becoming GM. Mike Mussina's free agent contract is #2. Yay Sabathia!
2009:
- Nothing but minor pitching moves to begin the year. Sabathia, Burnett, and Pettitte headlined the rotation. The Yankees inked some journeymen who might be able to fill-in in a pinch like Jason Johnson, Brett Tomko, Casey Fossum, Russ Ortiz, and Josh Towers. None really contributed much. Then there was the purchase of Chad Gaudin from the Padres. He wasn't terrible in 2009 as a spot starter/long man. The Yankees lost two more middling minor league pitchers to the Pirates in Steven Jackson and Anthony Claggett. But the Yankees were set as they made their run to the World Series and a Championship. They did it one the backs of essentially three pitchers, Sabathia, Pettitte, and Burnett.
- In December, the Yankees sent Brian Bruney to the Washington Nationals and instructed the Nats to select outfielder Jamie Hoffman in the Rule 5 Draft. Hoffman didn't make the Yankees and was returned to the Dodgers. Bruney has battled inconsistency and injury but the Nats got him for free.
- On December 8th, the Yankees completed a three-team trade that netted them Curtis Granderson. They gave up Ian Kennedy to the Diamondbacks (he won 21 games this season for them), Phil Coke and Austin Jackson to the Tigers. Yankee fans can't complain about the trade as Granderson was amazing last year. It is doubtful Kennedy could have been as good as he was as a Yankee. Phil Coke is a middling lefty reliever/starter who is left-handed (yes I know what I just typed).
- December 22nd was a weird day in Yankeeland. The Yankees sent young lefty Michael Dunn, Melky Cabrera, and minor league phenom Arodys Vizcaino to the Braves for Javier Vazquez and Boone Logan! Javy's back! Javy had gone on to quietly become one of the most consistent starting pitchers in baseball since leaving the Yanks and apparently Cashman didn't like that so he brought him back to the Bronx to ruin what remained of his life. In all seriousness, the Yankees probably shouldn't have traded Javier after one bad season and shouldn't have traded for him the second time around. Cashman loves bringing back pitchers for second looks for some reason. Well, Javier was worse this time around and Cashman had egg on his face. I mean, I don't understand what went wrong. Vazquez was, after all, coming off of a great year in the National League. I have no idea why it didn't translate.
2010:
- Sergio Mitre was re-signed. I forgot to mention when the Yankees orginally signed him in 2008. Oh well. He was originally Liebered, meaning he was injured when he signed his contract and Joe Girardi loved the guy so the Yankees thought it best to sign him, hold onto him, let him rehab and then boom! Only, the boom was supposed to be a good boom and not a bad one as Mitre ended up exploding all over the place. They are still trying to get the Mitre off the walls.
- February 28th, the Yankees signed Chan Ho Park. Park had been moderately successful in the National League before Cashman figured he would roll the dice, after all you can't fail on EVERY guy who succeeds in the NL and suddenly becomes a free agent afterward, right? Park was dreadful surrendering 7 homers in 35.1 innings. Yikes!
- May 12th, they Reduxed Tim Redding, only this time Redding never made it to the Bronx. Seriously, Cashman, what is your love affair with pitchers who weren't good enough the first time around.
-July 31st, the Yankees sent Mark Melancon and a minor leaguer to the Astros for Lance Berkman. Berkman wasn't good for the Yankees but rebounded with the Cardinals last year. Then Melancon suddenly became closer material and is now a set-up man for the Red Sox. Joy.
- In a seperate deal the Yankees acquired Kerry Wood from the Indians for two minor leaguers, one of whom was Matt Cusick. Wood was very good and helped bridge the gap to Mariano but he walked as a free agent at the end of the year. Still was a good move.
2011:
-Hello Bartolo! Bartolo Colon signed a deal with the Yankees as he attempted to make a comeback. It worked out much to everyone surprise.
- The Yankees signed Rafael Soriano, another expensive middle reliever, who had a weird first year with the Yankees. He was good and awful sometimes in the same inning. There were shades of Pavano there as well with weird injuries that were never explained. I'll give Cash a pass on him since he didn't really want him to begin with.
- Another big free agent signing was made right before the 2011 season. Pedro Feliciano, who had been abused so badly by the Mets that Cashman even criticized the MEts for his handling, was signed to a two-year deal. Feliciano's arm fell off and he will make $8 million over two years for NEVER throwing a pitch in a Yankee uniform. It's a shame too because he looked so good in those Spring Training warm-ups. This is one of the all-time worst signings by a Yankee GM.
- In February, the Yankees signed Freddy Garcia. Garcia was a bit of a gamble but it worked out and the Yankees brought him back to probably watch him come back to earth this season. Finding Freddy saved the Yanks last year, along with Bartolo.
- Luis Ayala was signed the same day as Garcia. He would have an excellent regular season as a middle reliever. He was cheap so of course he outperformed Soriano and Feliciano. See what I mean about bullpen arms? Anyway, he's an Oriole now so he might be their closer.
- On March 25th, the Yankees felt they needed an old veteran to go with all the other old vets so they signed Kevin Millwood for that just in case. They never broke the glass on him, thankfully.
- April 9th was the day the Yankees signed Carlos Silva to a contract. Another one I'm thankful never pitched in the Bronx.
- On June 16th the Yankees found Cory Wade sitting out there ready to give a good season's worth of work. Another cheap guy who outperformed the big contracts? Amazing.
- On June 29th Sergio Mitre threatened to show the world those nude photographs he has of Cashman unless Cashman traded for him and rescued him from Milwaukee. Mitre came and Yankee fans suffered.
- On July 14th, Cashman saw a lefty out there with experience in J.C. Romero. He signed Romero and stashed him in AAA. One cool thing to note, Romero has a 2011 Topps Update card of him in a Yankee uniform despite the fact that he never suited up for them. Yay airbrushes!
- Somehow, Scott Proctor escaped Joe Torre's grasp, made his way to Atlanta and Florida and then became a Yankee again and sacrificed himself for the good of getting shellacked. He would go out and try to get enough people out so that the Yankees could go home. RIP Scott Proctor.
- Just before the calendar turned to 2012, the Yankees signed Hideki Okajima, a lefty, to a minor league deal. Okajima might have three gallons left which should get him through Spring Training and earn him a spot to get shelled on the Major League roster.
2012:
- The Yankees traded top prospect Jesus Montero and Hector Noesi to the Mariners for Michael Pineda and minor leaguer Jose Campos. No comment can be made yet.
- Three days after getting Pineda, Cashman got Hiroki Kuroda to solidify the rotation. We shall see. Remember, National League guy....north of 35 years-old. Nothing can go wrong here, right? We'll see.
- Feb. 8th, the Yankees felt like Hideki Okajima, the former Red Sox needed a friend so they brought in Manny Delcarmen, the former Red Sox to fight for a spot in the bullpen. It is doubtful he does anything special but then again, it's a minor league deal so no harm, no foul.
There it is folks. No recap needed. Judge for yourself.
1998:
- Signed Orlando Hernandez as an amateur free agent. This move gets an A+. El Duque was one of the Yankees best starters in the postseason. There were few pitchers in baseball anyone trusted more with a game on the line.
- There wasn't much else to do to this team. The core was still together and the Yankees would roll to baseball's best record and eventually a World Series title.
1999:
- Brian Cashman had a bit of a problem. Scott Brosius was a clutch player, a good defensive third baseman, and fit in well with the Yankee scheme. The Yankees had a super third base prospect in Mike Lowell and had just drafted another third base phenom in the 1998 draft in Drew Henson. Cashman's solution was to trade the ready for the big league Mike Lowell to the Marlins for Ed Yarnall, Todd Noel, and Mark Johnson, three minor league pitchers. Yarnall at one time was considered one of the best left-handed pitching prospects in the game. Lowell would go on to win World Series titles with the Marlins and Red Sox and make 3 All-Star game appearances, and won a Gold Glove. For his career he managed to drive in 952 runs over 13 seasons, hit 223 home runs and produce an OPS (on base plus slugging percentage) of .805 for his career. Cashman's first major trade was a terrible one. Yarnall flamed out and would be traded to the Reds. Noel made a couple of relief appearances and would be gone. Johnson never made the Yankees.
- The second major trade for Brian Cashman was a blockbuster. He traded Homer Bush, Graeme Lloyd, and David Wells to the Blue Jays for Roger Clemens. This trade gets an A+ as Clemens helped lead the Yankees to two more World Series titles and won a Cy Young. I'm not getting into performance enhancing drugs here, you make your own call. David Wells, as we will see later would come back to the Yankees.
- The third trade of the year for Cashman came after the 1999 season, on December 22nd. He shipped Hideki Irabu off to the Montreal Expos for Jake Westbrook, Ted Lilly, and Christian Parker. Westbrook and Lilly would end up becoming reliable starters, both still pitching to this day. Unfortnately, neither of them did it with the Yankees for very long. Parker made one start for the Yankees and that was it. Westbrook and Lilly were two useable pitchers and Irabu had worn out his welcome in the Bronx. Good trade by Cashman.
2000:
- It was a minor move at the time but Cashman signed Chien Ming Wang to an amateur free agent contract. It would be a few years before people realized who Wang was but he would go on to win 19 games twice for the Yankees.
- Jake Westbrook didn't last long as a Yankee. He was shipped to the Indians with Zach Day, and Ricky Ledee in exchange for David Justice in June. Justice did help the Yankees limp into the playoffs and go on to win the 2000 World Series. Westbrook would go on to win 44 games between 2004 and 2006.
- The other mid-season trade occurred on July 12th when the Yankees acquired Denny Neagle from the Reds in exchange for Jackson Meilan, Drew Henson, Brian Reith, and Ed Yarnall. Neagle was supposed to stabilize a rotation that suddenly wasn't getting the job done. David Cone wasn't the same since his perfect game against the Expos. Neagle didn't do anything to help and the Yankees faded down the stretch and were lucky to make the playoffs. He would be allowed to leave as a free agent at the end of the season. However, none of the guys Cashman gave up made an impact in the big leagues. Henson was reacquired for Wily Mo Pena just before the start of the 2001 season.
- In December, Cashman signed Mike Mussina. Mussina would be the second best free agent singing Cashman has made behind C.C. Sabathia. There isn't much else to say about Moose, he was a good one.
2001:
- The first major pitching move, if you could call it that, was the acquisition of Enrique Wilson, a utility infielder in exchange for Damaso Marte. Marte will sound familiar to Yankee fans because in 2008, the Yankees acquired him from the Pirates to help fill the left-handed specialist role out of the bullpen. I don't know what Cashman was thinking. A hard-throwing lefty for a utility infielder who hit .216 as a Yankee. But hey, someone had to replace Luis Sojo, right? Yep, great move, or not.
- In June, the Yankees began to look for bullpen help. Jeff Nelson, the reliable set-up man, was gone. So, the Yankees shipped D'Angelo Jimenez to the Padres for reliever Jay Witasick. Witasick was not good but not awful but never earned Joe Torre's trust which might have saved his arm some major surgeries. Witasick would be traded at the end of the year to the Giants for John Van Der Wal, a spare outfielder and pinch-hitter.
- On July 1st, Cashman was on the troll again for relief help, trying to replace that Jeff Nelson fellow. This time he sent minor-leaguer Ricardo Aromboles to the Reds (there was a lot of trades with the Reds during this stretch wasn't there?) in exchange for Mark Wohlers, the former Braves closer mostly famous for giving up the game-tying home run to Jim Leyritz in the 1996 World Series. Wohlers wasn't very good. Not at all. Needless to say, Wohlers didn't win the set-up man role.
- On July 4th, the Yankees gave reliever Brian Boehringer his independence from the team and sent him to the Giants for backup catcher Bobby Estalella and minor leaguer Joe Smith. Boehringer pitched pretty well with the Yankees but I guess not good enough.
- On July 30th, the Yankees acquired a friendly face as they received Sterling Hitchcock from the Padres in exchange for Darren Blakely and Brett Jodie. Hitchcock was not very good as either a starter or reliever. But, the Yankees didn't give anything up to get him so you can't blame Cashman for rolling the dice on a guy who knew the Yankee clubhouse.
- After the season, the Yankees looked to the free agent market to fill the void left by Jeff Nelson's departure. They had to look somewhere since the trades Cashman made didn't work out. The first free agent reliever the Yankees gave a big contract to was Steve Karsay. Karsay wasn't bad. He was just never healthy. The Yankees spent $21 million for four years of a mostly injured Steve Karsay. He only appeared in 91 games, 78 of which came in his first year as a Yankee after only appearing in 31 the year before with the Indians. Thank you Joe Torre!
2002:
- Cashman kicked off the year by signing old friend David Wells as a free agent. Wells would go on to win 34 games for the Yankees over the next two years, the exact same number of wins he had in his first 2-year stint with the Yankees. This was a good move by Cashman.
- On July 5th, Cashman made one of the worst trades he has ever made. It was a three team deal that saw the Yankees send Ted Lilly, Jason Arnold, and John-Ford Griffin to the A's. The Yankees received Jeff Weaver from the Tigers. Weaver was a former first pick and never got into a groove on some awful Tigers teams. Lilly was being used as a spot-starter on the Yankees, never getting much of a chance except when there was an injury to one of the starters. Lilly would go on to win 115 games for the A's, Blue Jays, Cubs, and Dodgers. Weaver is out of baseball. Weaver was absolutely terrible as a Yankee, he went 12-12 with a 5.35 ERA, a 1.49 WHIP, and was even worse in the playoffs. Bad move. Lilly was, and has been a much better pitcher over the last decade than Weaver was over his entire career.
- After the 2002 season the Yankees began gearing up for 2003. In December, they signed Chris Hammond, a lefty reliever coming off of a monster year with the Braves. Hammond posted a 0.95 ERA and went 7-2 out of the bullpen for the Braves. Cashman was still trying to find the guy to set up for Mariano Rivera and Hammond was another roll of the dice, a pitcher coming off a career year. Hammond wasn't awful in Pinstripes, not by a long shot. He appeared in 62 games in 2003, posted a 3-2 mark with a 2.86 ERA and 1.20 WHIP. Steady numbers. He was traded following the 2003 season as we will see later.
2003:
- Cashman started the year by shipping Orlando Hernandez to the White Sox in exchange for middle reliever Antonio Osuna and a minor leaguer whose mother never knew he played baseball, Delvis Lantigua. The White Sox flipped El Duque and some minor leaguers/fringe major leaguers a few days later to the Expos for Bartolo Colon, who was acquired by then-Expos GM Omar Minaya in exchange for Cliff Lee, Grady Sizemore, and Brandon Phillips the year before. El Duque never pitched for the Expos due to injury. I guess getting Osuna, who at least pitched that year in exchange for someone who didn't pitch at all is a win.
- Another middle reliever was signed, this time it was Juan Acevedo. Acevedo was coming off of a career year with the Tigers and Cashman hoped he could maybe step in as a dependable reliever. Yeah, that didn't happen and Acevedo was released in June and was out of baseball by the next year.
- In February, Cashman signed Jon Lieber to a two-year contract. Leiber was a former 20 game winner with the Cubs but had just undergone Tommy John surgery. The first year Leiber rehabbed his arm. The second year, 2004, Leiber would become arguably the best Yankee pitcher down the stretch. A risky but smart move by Cashman.
- Two days later, Cashman swooped in and stole Jose Contreras out from under the Red Sox nose and signed the Cuban star as a free agent. Contreras was supposed to be Luis Tiant reincarnated. Well, he wasn't. He is still pitching as a reliever and is fairly decent but the Yankees got little to return on Contreras except the "Evil Empire" moniker that Red Sox President Larry Lucchino placed up the Yankees.
- The search for quality relief led Cashman to swing another trade in July, this time acquiring Armando Benitez from the Mets in exchange for Jason Anderson, and two other minor leaguers whose mothers didn't even know they played baseball. Benitez is the rare guy who actually pitched worse than his 1-1 record and 1.93 ERA as evidenced by his 1.50 WHIP. He blew a game against the Red Sox and that led the "can't handle the big game" label to be placed squarely on Armando's back. He would have one more season, as the Marlins closer, that was good before imploding faster than a sinking Russian nuclear sub. We will soon find out Mr. Benitez's fate with the Yankees. Here's a hint, he only pitched in 9 games for them.
- Cashman continued to look for bullpen help, this time getting Jesse Orosco from the Padres. Orosco was 46 years-old at the time and was expected to be the lefty-specialist the Yankees needed. Well, it didn't work out and Orosco called it a career after getting dealt to the Twins. He did put up some interesting numbers as a Yankee though. They include a 10.38 ERA, 4.1 innings across 15 games, and a WHIP of 2.308. I seriously might have been able to do just as bad, maybe even better.
- With Orosco not working out, Cashman swung another deal with the Reds, this time getting Gabe White as part of a conditional deal. White wasn't the answer either but since nothing big was given up for White Cashman gets a pass on this deal. It was just another transaction in a long line of transactions for middle relievers that never seemed to work out.
- At the trade deadline, Cashman traded a fading Robin Ventura to the Dodgers for outfielder Bubba Crosby and reliever Scott Proctor. It would be a little while for Proctor to make his Yankees debut and his arm would never be the same as Joe Torre trusted him and rode Proctor into the ground, literally ruining his career and blowing out his arm. At the time, this seemed like a good trade. Ventura was a shell of his former self and the Yankees had Aaron Boone coming in from the Reds. Proctor, at time, seemed like he might be the guy who could bridge the gap from starters to Mariano. Then Joe Torre happened.
- In August of 2003, the Yankees had tired of Armando Benitez and shipped him to the Mariners for Jeff Nelson. The Yankees had been trying to find a replacement for Nelson ever since Nelson left. They didn't want to pay Nelson a crazy amount of money and instead wound up spending more on guys who couldn't replace him. The sad thing was, Nelson was not the Jeff Nelson the Yankees remembered and he would be gone at the end of the year and the quest to find a replacement for Jeff Nelson continued.
- In December of 2003, only a couple of months after the Yankees lost the World Series to the Marlins, Cashman found himself trying to replace 3/5ths of his starting rotation. Andy Pettitte signed with the Astros. Roger Clemens retired and then unretired and signed with the Astros. David Wells was allowed to leave as a free agent as he was getting old and his chronic medical problems made him a little too risky going forward. Enter Kevin Brown. Brown was coming off an excellent year with the Dodgers and the Yankees needed pitchers. Brown was, at the time, signed to a ridiculous contract and the Yankees had money to burn. They shipped Yhency Brazoban, failure Jeff Weaver, and Brandon Weeden (who is now hoping to be drafted in the NFL after being a fairly successful QB in college this past season) to the Dodgers for Brown. The problem was Brown was 39 years old when he pitched for the Yankees, made a ton of money, and was now expected to jump alongside Mike Mussina as the teams new 1-2 punch. Well, it didn't work out that way and Yankee fans remember Brown as one of the reasons the Red Sox did what they did in 2004 and also for punching a wall with his hand and missing several starts because of it. Failure.
- Three days after getting Brown, the Yankees addressed their rotation again, obtaining Javier Vazquez from the Expos in exchange for Nick Johnson, Randy Choate, and Juan Rivera. Vazquez was supposed to be the new Pedro Martinez, a good pitcher in Montreal being held back by a terrible team. Vazquez would make the 2004 All-Star team because he did pitch well the first half of the season and it looked like the Yankees had a new, young, stud pitcher going forward. Then the second-half collapse came and Javier's ERA exploded. He wasn't much better in the playoffs, in fact he was worse. The Yankees cut ties with Javy after the season.
- The day after the Yankees got Javy, they signed Paul Quantrill, another reliever they hoped would carry the success from the previous year's career year into the Yankee bullpen. Quantrill was a proven workhorse, someone Joe Torre could ride forever. He led the league in appearances the previous three years and was fairly successful. One of those seasons was even in the American League East with the Blue Jays. Well, Quantrill would be ridden hard by Joe Torre in 2004, even if he wasn't very effective. He led the league once again in appearances with 86! However, he was a mid-thirties pitcher with a million miles on his arm and Cashman still gave him $3 million per year. Ugggh!
- Chris Hammond was shipped away to the A's for two minor leaguers that never helped the Yankees at all. Granted, Hammond was 37 going on 38 when the Yankees traded him but he had shown he could be fairly successful out of the bullpen. He had a couple of decent years left in him before retiring. Eh, whatever, right?
- On December 16th, the Yankees thought they found the answer to their set-up man question. Tom Gordon was signed to be that guy. He was good but not great. In 2004, he was very good, then hit a bit of wall in the playoffs, probably from being abused by Joe Torre. He was abused once again in 2005, appearing in 79 games after getting into 80 games in 2004. At 38 years-old, the Yankees figured they used up all of the good Tom Gordon and let him walk via free agency after 2005.
2004:
- The year started off kind of slow pitching wise. The Yankees had made their big splashes at the end of 2003 to get ready for the 2004 season. They would trade Alfonso Soriano for Alex Rodriguez. Bring in the washed-up Donovan Osborne and actually allow him to pitch big league innings.
- Orlando Hernandez was brought back and he pitched fairly well between injuries.
- In May, the Yankees made a minor deal that sent a minor leaguer to the Dodgers and received Tanyon Sturtze. Poor Sturtze would become trusted by Joe Torre who developed weird relationships with relievers that he trusted, even if they weren't the best out there. He would then ride those men into the ground out of fear of giving the ball to someone else. I think Torre suffered from PTSD after Nelson and Mike Stanton left.
- Gabe White was sent back to the Reds in June for Charlie Manning and cash. Manning was one of the pitching prospects the Yankees sent to the Reds in one of their 4,000 deals over the last couple of years.
- In July, the Yankees signed amateur free agent Ivan Nova. Looking good so far.
- At the July 31st trading deadline, the Yankees sent Jose Contreras packing, finally having seen enough of him. He was sent to the White Sox for Esteban Loaiza who miraculously won 21 games the year before with the White Sox and then imploded. Loaiza is gone from baseball. Contreras is still pitching out of the bullpen.
- In December, after the Red Sox bounced the patched together Yankees from the ALCS, Cashman went out and brought in Mike Stanton, who was another reliever Joe Torre couldn't live without in exchange for Felix Heredia. Stanton had been on the Mets the previous two years and was now a 38 year-old relief pitcher. Well, Stanton was awful and would be released after appearing in just 28 games with the 2005 Yankees. Bringing Jeff Nelson back to replace Jeff Nelson didn't work and bringing Mike Stanton back rto replace Mike Stanton didn't work.
- To help bolster the bullpen, (see a theme here with a lot of these trades and signings?) the Yankees shipped a disgruntled Kenny Lofton to the Phillies for a hard-throwing reliever named Felix Rodriguez. F-Rod was only 32 years-old and had been one of the better relievers over the last few seasons...in the National League. Needless to say, Rodriguez didn't last with the Yankees and was allowed to walk as a free agent after the 2005 season.
- Kevin Brown, and Javier Vazquez weren't working out for the Yankees. Esteban Loaiza didn't work out. Jon Leiber was a free agent. The Yankees once again needed pitching help. In December of 2004, the Yankees tried to bring in pitchers that would prevent the Red Sox from embarrassing them in the playoffs ever again. Enter Carl Pavano and Jaret Wright. Pavano was signed on Dec. 20th and Wright was signed Dec. 28th. Pavano was given a 4-year contract worth over $40 million. Jaret Wright, coming off that career year in the National League was given $21 over 3 years. Well, Pavano made 26 starts for the Yankees...over the entire length of the contract. He missed all of 2006 and never made more than 17 starts in a season. Of course, I forgot to mention Carl Pavano was also coming off a career year in the NAtional League and the Yankees remembered him from the 2003 World Series. There is nothing else that needs to be said...go up to a Yankee fan and mention Carl Pavano and their reaction will tell you all you need to know.
- Jaret Wright was the other big free agent signing that was supposed to remake the Yankees rotation. He was a power pitcher and...well he wasn't the same pitcher that dominated Yankee bats in the 1997 AL Playoffs that's for sure. I don't know what the Yankees were thinking giving Jaret Wright that contract.
2005:
- Javy Vazquez was considered a failure after one season in the Bronx. The Yankees needed dominant pitching. Enter Randy Johnson. The Big Unit was acquired from the Dimaondbacks in exchange for Javy, Brad Halsey, and Dioner Navarro. Randy Johnson was coming off a year where he struck out 290 batters to lead the Majors. George Steinbrenner had a thing for Johnson ever since he was a Mariner. Of course, he was past 40 when the Yankees acquired him and he pitched better than most 40 year-olds probably could. He won 34 games as a Yankee over 2 seasons. His first season in Pinstripes was pretty good, winning 17 games and posting a 3.79 ERA and piling up 211 strikeouts. But, Randy was a cantankerous soul and would be gone from the Yankees after only two year. Javier Vazquez has actually outpitched Randy Johnson since the trade and is 10 years younger. But, hey, mess up once with the Yankees and you gotta get packing.
- In February, the Yankees brought back Ramiro Mendoza. He was another former Yankee bullpen arm that they always had trouble replacing. Like Jeff Nelson and Mike Stanton before him, Mendoza's second time with the Yankees was forgettable. He appeared in 1 game and was gone from baseball.
- Speaking of returns, Brian Boehringer was signed on July 1st, his third go around with the Yankees. When in doubt bring in a familiar face, eh Brian? Less than a month later he was released without ever appearing in a game.
- Paul Quantrill, the used up middle reliever, was used as trade bait to help out the Yankee rotation which was injury plagued to say the least. Come on, Jaret Wright and Carl Pavano people. Kevin Brown who last played with Ty Cobb, and Randy Johnson who George sometimes called Walter...old and beat up were the Yankees. In return for Quantrill, the Yankees receiver Darrell May and Tim Redding. They needed people to fill in as starters and they picked the two most unqualified guys to ever do that. May was a 33 year-old wannabe Major Leaguer. Redding was a little younger, 27, and both were equally horrible in Pinstripes. However, the Yankees farm system didn't have much in the way of Major League-ready arms with the exception of Chien Ming Wang and this is what they had to resort to to try and fill in some starts.
- After May and Redding flamed out, the Yankees acquired Al Letier from the Marlins as part of a conditional deal. Leiter was 39 and nearing the end of a very successful career. Sadly, he wasn't the answer either.
- Just a few days before the trading deadline, the Yankees were still looking for someone to pitch some innings from the 5th spot in the rotation. So they acquired Shawn Chacon from the Rockies for Eduardo Sierra and Ramon Ramirez. Chacon was a flash in the pan, pitching well his first year with the Yankees and stabilizing the back end of the rotation along with fellow flash in the pan Aaron Small. By the next year Chacon was awful...or normal, and he was shipped to the Pirates for Craig Wilson in 2006.
- I bet most Yankee fans don't remember how desperate they were for pitching that year. Well, they signed Hideo Nomo at one point, though he never appeared in a game for them. He was a washed-up shell of his former self.
- The bullpen was still a mish-mash and the Yankees were in need of a left-handed reliever. Sound familiar? Well enter Alan Embree, formerly of the Red Sox. Exit Alan Embree after posting a 7.53 ERA in 24 appearances spanning 14.1 innings.
- Bullpen problems? What bullpen problems? The Yankees acquired Ron Villone from the Marlins in exchange for a minor leaguer. Villone was a lefty. Maybe he could get lefty hitters out. Right?
- In December, after letting tom Gordon walk via free agency, the Yankees found hard-throwing Kyle Farnsworth sitting out there, waiting to have money thrown at him. Cashman had the money and he did the throwing, inking Farnsworth to a 3 year, $18 million contract. Farnsworth was coming off a good season that he split between Detroit and Atlanta, had never shown consistent stuff but had a lively fastball and sometimes had a nasty slider. Oh, what a Jeff Nelson he could be, Cashman probably thought to himself. He resembled the second coming of Jeff Nelson more than the first and was traded in his thrid year with the team. If he had been healthy all year long Joe Torre might have blown out his arm and saved other managers the frustration of having to put Farnsworth in the game. In all seriousness he is a nice guy and is a serviceable middle reliever, just not worth the money the Yankees threw at him with the expectations that came with it. Another middle-reliever fail.
- Then, on December 15th, the Yankees signed Mike Myers. The answer to the Mike Stanton replacement question...at the moment. Myers was a lefty, was 37 years old, and, did I mention he was a lefty? Myers was going to finally be the guy to get out David Ortiz. Myers wasn't awful but he was frustrating. He would get out a righty, face Ortiz and give up a homer. Or he would give up a base-hit to the only lefty he would face, leave the game and get ready for tomorrow's lefty hitter. He wasn't consistent and was maddening every bit as much as Boone Logan is today. Maybe more so. Middle relief fail #3,906.
2006:
- The bullpen was still up in the air...as if it had ever been settled since 2000, so the Yankees signed Octavio Dotel to a contract. Dotel, like Leiber before him, was rehabbing from surgery but it was a low-risk, potential high reward deal. Dotel pitched in 14 games for the 2006 yankees, wasn't very good and was allowed to leave as a free agent. Dotel would recover fully from his surgery and be a pretty good reliever and is still pitching today at age 37.
- Some minor pitching moves took place in January and February. Ramiro Mendoza was signed to a free agent contract. Presumably to replace himself. Darrell Rasner was claimed off of waivers from the Washington Nationals. Mendoza never appeared in a game again in baseball and Rasner would be a somewhat decent fill-in starter for the Yankees over the next couple of years before taking his talents to Asia. The Yankees also signed 38 year0old Scott Erickson to a deal. That would have been awesome if this were 1990, not 2006. Erickson was done, washed up and used. He still made it into 9 games with the Yankees before Cashman realized there were better options out there.
- On July 1st, the Yankees took a chance on the recently released Brian Bruney. Bruney had an excellent fastball and had had problems controlling that pitch. He would become a pretty good bullpen guy before losing his control again and some fastball velocity. But the bullpen is the most volatile part of any teams roster and a roll of the dice with a guy like Bruney can sometimes heap huge rewards. you don't have to spend $21 million over 4 years for a reliever.
- For some reason Cashman had a short obsession with washed-up former Orioles. First it was Scott Erickson then came Sidney Ponson. Ponson somehow managed to make 3 starts and 2 relief appearances in 2006 for the Yankees. He was released just over a month later, in August. What is even crazier is that he was brought back in 2008 as we will see later.
- On August 11th, Cashman signed John Axford to a minor league deal. Axford didn't do anything special for the Yankees but has gone on to become one of the best closers in baseball. Weird how that works sometimes, huh?
- On November 10th, tired of the Gary Sheffield act, and with Bobby Abreu now in right field, the Yankees shipped Sheff to the Tigers for three minor league pitchers, Anthony Claggett, Kevin Whelan, and Humberto Sanchez. Whelan is the only one still in the Yankees organization, but all three made appearances for the Yankees. Claggett was awful. Sanchez never recovered from the arm surgery, and Whelan is a AAA closer that has trouble finding the strike zone too often. All that for Gary Sheffield!
- On November 12th, the Yankees shipped Jaret Wright who was terrible as a starter to the Orioles for reliever Chris Britton. Britton would become somewhat famous for seemingly using up all of his options in the span of seven minutes as the Yankees shuttled him back and forth between Scranton and New York in 2007.
- On December 8th, the Yankees went all redux again, this time successfully. They brought back Andy Pettitte. I don't need to say anything more about Andy.
- On December 19th, after watching the Red Sox sign Daisuke Matsuzaka, the Yankees dipped back into the Japanese leagues. This time they came up with Kei Igawa, and gave him a 5 year deal worth $4 million a year. He made most of his money setting AA and AAA pitching records. Good for him, I guess. Igawa will forever be the ink stain on Cashman's shirt. He appeared in 16 game, 13 starts, for the Yankees, posted an ungodly ERA of 6.66 (see what I did there?) and allowed 15 homers in 71.2 innings. Yikes! The saga of Igawa is sad. the guy wanted to pitch, he never gave up, even when the Yankees offered to end the pain. He is a free agent now, and Brian Cashman can sleep at night...sort of...when stalkers aren't ringing his doorbell I guess.
2007:
- The Yankees had let the Randy Johnson experiment go on far too long. He was miserable, fans were miserable, and Cashman was miserable. On January 9th, he was dealt to the Diamondbacks for Luis Vizcaino (he might be an answer as a middle reliever, hopefully, maybe?), minor league shortstop Alberto Gonzalez, and minor league pitchers Ross Ohlendorf and Steven Jackson. All of these guys would see time with the big club. Ohlendorf, who will pop up again later, was the best of the bunch. Vizcaino followed Octavio Dotel, Tom Gordon, Kyle Farnsworth, Felix Rodriguez, etc. out of town.
- May 6th, Susan Waldman makes hysterical noises on the radio, yelling "Roger Clemens is in Gawge Steinbrennah's bawx!" a few thousand times as the Yankees dramatically announced Roger Clemens would be coming back to join Andy Pettitte back in the Bronx. Roger was later seen bench pressing the Old Yankee Stadium which would ruin the foundation of the landmark and lead the Yankees to have to build a whole new Stadium. OK, that last part isn't true.
- Bye-bye Scott Proctor. At the trading deadline, the Yankees shipped Scott Proctor off to the Dodgers in exchange for utility guy Wilson Betemit. Scott Proctor, who somehow managed to make an appearance in every Yankee game since Billy Martin was manager, was probably very glad to get away from Joe Torre who actually held Proctor hostage in the bullpen chained to a wall and fed leftover hot dogs. OK, that's not true but it sure seemed like it. Proctor would later wonder what he did to piss God off when Torre followed him out to Los Angeles a year later.
- On December 4th, the Yankees traded one of their top pitching prospects, Tyler Clippard to the Washington Nationals for reliever Jonathan Alabadejo. Clippard had a very nive MLB debut against the Mets but Cashman got impatient. Clippard is now famous for "Clipparding" wins in Washington where he actually made the All-Star team last season. He is the vulture extraordinaire, getting wins and pitching well despite not pitching well. Wish I could do that. Either way, this was a win for the Nats. Alabadejo used the Scranton Shuttle almost as often as Chris Britton.
- On December 12th, the Yankees remembered Andy Pettitte was a free agent, unlike in 2003, and they actually re-signed him! Hooray!
- On December 21st, the Yankees thought they had themselves a new bullpen arm when they inked LaTroy Hawkins to a contract worht over $3 million per year. Hawkins was coming off of a sensational year and Cashman finally thought this was the year the pitcher coming off of a career year in the NL would translate into the AL in Pinstripes. Except the story didn't end up that way. Hawkins went from having a good year with Colorado in 2007, to being God-awful for the Yankees in 2008, to being dominant for the Astros after the Yankees traded him in June for Matt Cusick. Wow, great job.
2008:
- The Yankees had been scrap-heaping arms in AAA. They signed Billy Traber (lefty!) and Heath Phillips (lefty!) to minor league deals in January. Traber made the show and showed everyone he wasn't cut out for Major League Baseball. Phillips was replacement level at AAA.
- In February, the Yankees signed a little-known Mexican Leaguer named Alfredo Aceves to a deal. Aceves would become a kind of better version of Ramiro Mendoza, spot starting and relieving and vulturing wins. alas, he had trouble staying healthy and the Yankees didn't offer him a Major League contract after the 2010 season so he went to the Red Sox for 2011, battled injuries, and filled in nicely as a starter. Oh well.
- June 19th, 2008...Welcome back Sidney Ponson! Oh, you still are terrible. Darn.
- July 11th, wow, Eric Milton is a Yankee again! The top pitching prospect that was traded for Chuck Knoblauch signs a minor league deal. He never throws a pitch for the Yankees because of injuries. Not sure if Cashman was trying to Leiber him but it didn't work.
- Three days before the non-waiver trade deadline in July, the Yankees package Jose Tabata, Ross Ohlendorf, Jeff Karstens, and Daniel McCutcheon to the Pirates in exchange for Xavier Nady and Damaso Marte. Marte was traded to the Pirates years before if you recall and the Yankees really needed that lefty reliever. Nady was that extra bat the Yankees needed to propel them into the playoffs. Only they missed the playoffs in 2008. Shucks. Karstens is somehow still pitching in Pittsburgh. Ohlendorf is now a free agent and is still fairly young (redux?). Tabata, once a top prospect, has some age issues, is married to Martha Washington's slightly younger sister, had thought about quitting baseball in 2008, and is now a decent enough outfielder for the Pirates. The Pirates win this deal because they got players who are still playing for them. Nady is gone from the Yankees. Marte had a decent World Series run in 2009, got re-signed, and hurt himself. Or maybe he robbed a bank and ran away. Who knows? Who cares?
- July 30th saw the Yankees make two trades, the LaTroy Hawkins trade with Houston and they actually found a taker for Kyle Farnsworth, sending him to the tigers in exchange for Ivan Rodriguez. Yes, Pudge Rodriguez. Same guy, different decade.
- In December of 2008, the Yankees lost Ivan Nova in the Rule 5 Draft to the San Diego Padres. Luckily for the Yankees, they returned him. Phew!
- Having just missed the playoffs, Brian Cashman and George Steinbrenner decided they were not gonna let that happen again. So the first strike in free agency was for A.J. Burnett, the very pitcher who inspired this post to begin with. Burnett had a decent year in 2009. a terrible one in 2010. And a blah, bad one in 2011. The Yankees have two years left of Burnett that they are trying to unload on someone (Pirates?) and a total of $33 million. Yikes! That contract hasn't worked out at all like the Yankees hoped. At least he wasn't Pavano or Igawa, right? Right?
- Just days after inking the inked up Burnett, Cashman landed his man, C.C. Sabathia to a monster deal. Mussina was retiring and the Yankees needed an ace. Wang was done with the Yankees, and the Yankees needed an ace. Did I mention they needed an ace? Anyway, Sabathia is Cashman's best move and his best pitching move since becoming GM. Mike Mussina's free agent contract is #2. Yay Sabathia!
2009:
- Nothing but minor pitching moves to begin the year. Sabathia, Burnett, and Pettitte headlined the rotation. The Yankees inked some journeymen who might be able to fill-in in a pinch like Jason Johnson, Brett Tomko, Casey Fossum, Russ Ortiz, and Josh Towers. None really contributed much. Then there was the purchase of Chad Gaudin from the Padres. He wasn't terrible in 2009 as a spot starter/long man. The Yankees lost two more middling minor league pitchers to the Pirates in Steven Jackson and Anthony Claggett. But the Yankees were set as they made their run to the World Series and a Championship. They did it one the backs of essentially three pitchers, Sabathia, Pettitte, and Burnett.
- In December, the Yankees sent Brian Bruney to the Washington Nationals and instructed the Nats to select outfielder Jamie Hoffman in the Rule 5 Draft. Hoffman didn't make the Yankees and was returned to the Dodgers. Bruney has battled inconsistency and injury but the Nats got him for free.
- On December 8th, the Yankees completed a three-team trade that netted them Curtis Granderson. They gave up Ian Kennedy to the Diamondbacks (he won 21 games this season for them), Phil Coke and Austin Jackson to the Tigers. Yankee fans can't complain about the trade as Granderson was amazing last year. It is doubtful Kennedy could have been as good as he was as a Yankee. Phil Coke is a middling lefty reliever/starter who is left-handed (yes I know what I just typed).
- December 22nd was a weird day in Yankeeland. The Yankees sent young lefty Michael Dunn, Melky Cabrera, and minor league phenom Arodys Vizcaino to the Braves for Javier Vazquez and Boone Logan! Javy's back! Javy had gone on to quietly become one of the most consistent starting pitchers in baseball since leaving the Yanks and apparently Cashman didn't like that so he brought him back to the Bronx to ruin what remained of his life. In all seriousness, the Yankees probably shouldn't have traded Javier after one bad season and shouldn't have traded for him the second time around. Cashman loves bringing back pitchers for second looks for some reason. Well, Javier was worse this time around and Cashman had egg on his face. I mean, I don't understand what went wrong. Vazquez was, after all, coming off of a great year in the National League. I have no idea why it didn't translate.
2010:
- Sergio Mitre was re-signed. I forgot to mention when the Yankees orginally signed him in 2008. Oh well. He was originally Liebered, meaning he was injured when he signed his contract and Joe Girardi loved the guy so the Yankees thought it best to sign him, hold onto him, let him rehab and then boom! Only, the boom was supposed to be a good boom and not a bad one as Mitre ended up exploding all over the place. They are still trying to get the Mitre off the walls.
- February 28th, the Yankees signed Chan Ho Park. Park had been moderately successful in the National League before Cashman figured he would roll the dice, after all you can't fail on EVERY guy who succeeds in the NL and suddenly becomes a free agent afterward, right? Park was dreadful surrendering 7 homers in 35.1 innings. Yikes!
- May 12th, they Reduxed Tim Redding, only this time Redding never made it to the Bronx. Seriously, Cashman, what is your love affair with pitchers who weren't good enough the first time around.
-July 31st, the Yankees sent Mark Melancon and a minor leaguer to the Astros for Lance Berkman. Berkman wasn't good for the Yankees but rebounded with the Cardinals last year. Then Melancon suddenly became closer material and is now a set-up man for the Red Sox. Joy.
- In a seperate deal the Yankees acquired Kerry Wood from the Indians for two minor leaguers, one of whom was Matt Cusick. Wood was very good and helped bridge the gap to Mariano but he walked as a free agent at the end of the year. Still was a good move.
2011:
-Hello Bartolo! Bartolo Colon signed a deal with the Yankees as he attempted to make a comeback. It worked out much to everyone surprise.
- The Yankees signed Rafael Soriano, another expensive middle reliever, who had a weird first year with the Yankees. He was good and awful sometimes in the same inning. There were shades of Pavano there as well with weird injuries that were never explained. I'll give Cash a pass on him since he didn't really want him to begin with.
- Another big free agent signing was made right before the 2011 season. Pedro Feliciano, who had been abused so badly by the Mets that Cashman even criticized the MEts for his handling, was signed to a two-year deal. Feliciano's arm fell off and he will make $8 million over two years for NEVER throwing a pitch in a Yankee uniform. It's a shame too because he looked so good in those Spring Training warm-ups. This is one of the all-time worst signings by a Yankee GM.
- In February, the Yankees signed Freddy Garcia. Garcia was a bit of a gamble but it worked out and the Yankees brought him back to probably watch him come back to earth this season. Finding Freddy saved the Yanks last year, along with Bartolo.
- Luis Ayala was signed the same day as Garcia. He would have an excellent regular season as a middle reliever. He was cheap so of course he outperformed Soriano and Feliciano. See what I mean about bullpen arms? Anyway, he's an Oriole now so he might be their closer.
- On March 25th, the Yankees felt they needed an old veteran to go with all the other old vets so they signed Kevin Millwood for that just in case. They never broke the glass on him, thankfully.
- April 9th was the day the Yankees signed Carlos Silva to a contract. Another one I'm thankful never pitched in the Bronx.
- On June 16th the Yankees found Cory Wade sitting out there ready to give a good season's worth of work. Another cheap guy who outperformed the big contracts? Amazing.
- On June 29th Sergio Mitre threatened to show the world those nude photographs he has of Cashman unless Cashman traded for him and rescued him from Milwaukee. Mitre came and Yankee fans suffered.
- On July 14th, Cashman saw a lefty out there with experience in J.C. Romero. He signed Romero and stashed him in AAA. One cool thing to note, Romero has a 2011 Topps Update card of him in a Yankee uniform despite the fact that he never suited up for them. Yay airbrushes!
- Somehow, Scott Proctor escaped Joe Torre's grasp, made his way to Atlanta and Florida and then became a Yankee again and sacrificed himself for the good of getting shellacked. He would go out and try to get enough people out so that the Yankees could go home. RIP Scott Proctor.
- Just before the calendar turned to 2012, the Yankees signed Hideki Okajima, a lefty, to a minor league deal. Okajima might have three gallons left which should get him through Spring Training and earn him a spot to get shelled on the Major League roster.
2012:
- The Yankees traded top prospect Jesus Montero and Hector Noesi to the Mariners for Michael Pineda and minor leaguer Jose Campos. No comment can be made yet.
- Three days after getting Pineda, Cashman got Hiroki Kuroda to solidify the rotation. We shall see. Remember, National League guy....north of 35 years-old. Nothing can go wrong here, right? We'll see.
- Feb. 8th, the Yankees felt like Hideki Okajima, the former Red Sox needed a friend so they brought in Manny Delcarmen, the former Red Sox to fight for a spot in the bullpen. It is doubtful he does anything special but then again, it's a minor league deal so no harm, no foul.
There it is folks. No recap needed. Judge for yourself.
Monday, February 13, 2012
It IS Linsane
I still can't believe the hype surrounding Jeremy Lin of the New York Knicks. The guy has been phenomenal, don't get me wrong, but he has played less than a week of basketball at this level and has yet to play with the Knicks two biggest stars, Amar'e Stoudemire and Carmelo Anthony. Lin has been the answer for the Knicks after they lost Anthony to injury and Stoudemire to the death of his brother. However, Stoudemire is back and I don't see a problem with him playing with Lin. Instead, I see Melo being the question because Melo almost demands that the offense run through him. Look at what has happened to Stoudemire's stats since Melo joined the team as exhibit A.
Anyway, this blog isn't about how Jeremy Lin is going to fit in with the Knicks. I'm sure he will be fine. This post is about the insanity, or should I say Linsanity, surrounding everything Jeremy Lin. A quick scan of eBay will show astronomical prices on some Jeremy Lin rookie cards. Three weeks ago, people couldn't give these cards away. How much value did a guy who was cut by the Golden State Warriors and Houston Rockets and riding the bench for the Knicks warrant? None. Then, Lin started playing, and the Knicks started winning. That once worthless basketball card is now selling for $20 in most cases. Here is the link to an offering for a Jeremy Lin autographed RC going for $199.50 (with less than two minutes left as I write this)http://www.ebay.com/itm/JEREMY-LIN-2010-11-PANINI-TIMELESS-TREASURES-CARD-AUTO-10-299-ROOKIE-KNICKS-/320847880837?pt=LH_DefaultDomain_0&hash=item4ab4062285.
It's crazy. It's Linsane! Want more? Just type in Jeremy Lin on eBay, or follow this link and prepare to be shocked. His jersey is selling out faster than stores can replenish them. He is putting the Knicks back on the radar because he has people excited again. For all of the hype that surrounded the Knicks going into this season with Stoudemire and Melo, and Tyson Chandler, it was Lin that made Knicks fans believe. Why?
In the sports world when you have someone come from out of nowhere and enjoy success it excites fans mostly because the fans can dream about doing it themselves. What kid wouldn't love to take Kobe to school on the court? Jeremy Lin never went to school at a basketball powerhouse. He was a HArvard boy with enough talent to barely get a look in the NBA. Then, all of a sudden, like Robert Redford in The Natural, he is hitting game winning shots and putting up rookie numbers that haven't been seen in a long time. With this type of success you will have people looking to cash in, especially on the secondary market.
Enter the eBay Lin craze. Enter the Lin craze in general. In a society fueled by the need to have the latest and greatest, people are running out and buying everything Jeremy Lin. Jeremy Lin is the new iPhone of the NBA. Everyone has to have his jersey. People want his autograph. People need to follow him on Twitter (his account by the way now has 217,195 followers as of 2:27 PM on Feb. 13th). People want to feel a part of "IT", whatever "IT" is. Right now, Jeremy Lin is "it" because he has helped turn around the Knicks season which was looking like it was going to be a huge disappointment. In a city with over 8 million people and a metro area of about 14 million, being the next big thing is huge. We have all seen the Facebook and Twitter posts of our friends who are suddenly interested in Knicks basketball again, even if the last Knick they could name was Patrick Ewing.
Jeremy Lin is bringing the swagger back to New York, especially on the heels of the New York Giants winning the Super Bowl. New York is becoming cool again in sports. Even the New York Rangers are atop the NHL standings and the Yankees are poised for another playoff run. New York has had it's share of winners over the years but the Knicks haven't had much success since Patrick Ewing left and now, with the help of a scrawny Harvard kid, the Knicks are relevant again in a way that might even make Patrick jealous.
So, will the Jeremy Lin market crash? In a conversation on Twitter with Beckett editor, Chris Olds, who clearly has a pulse on the card market, he believes there is a chance for the Lin market, at least the Lin card market to sustain these prices if people start putting them away and not flooding the market with it. He is right. There are limited numbers of these cards since card companies, like Panini, are not overproducing cards like they did in the 1980's and 1990's. If people are putting the Lin's away into their personal collections and the demand remains high then there won't be a crash. My personal belief is that greed will win out and these cards will keep on getting posted, especially if the Knicks make the playoffs and Jeremy Lin continues this absurd level of playing. People will always look to cash in. It's human nature. There will be a few who will keep their Jeremy Lin rookie cards, if I had one I might take advantage of the craze and post it up for sale but if I had doubles I would keep one for my own collection.
Bottom line, if you think the Jeremy Lin craze is at a fever pitch now, just wait if the Knicks get to the NBA Finals and this kid is still playing at this level. You ain't seen nothing yet.
Anyway, this blog isn't about how Jeremy Lin is going to fit in with the Knicks. I'm sure he will be fine. This post is about the insanity, or should I say Linsanity, surrounding everything Jeremy Lin. A quick scan of eBay will show astronomical prices on some Jeremy Lin rookie cards. Three weeks ago, people couldn't give these cards away. How much value did a guy who was cut by the Golden State Warriors and Houston Rockets and riding the bench for the Knicks warrant? None. Then, Lin started playing, and the Knicks started winning. That once worthless basketball card is now selling for $20 in most cases. Here is the link to an offering for a Jeremy Lin autographed RC going for $199.50 (with less than two minutes left as I write this)http://www.ebay.com/itm/JEREMY-LIN-2010-11-PANINI-TIMELESS-TREASURES-CARD-AUTO-10-299-ROOKIE-KNICKS-/320847880837?pt=LH_DefaultDomain_0&hash=item4ab4062285.
It's crazy. It's Linsane! Want more? Just type in Jeremy Lin on eBay, or follow this link and prepare to be shocked. His jersey is selling out faster than stores can replenish them. He is putting the Knicks back on the radar because he has people excited again. For all of the hype that surrounded the Knicks going into this season with Stoudemire and Melo, and Tyson Chandler, it was Lin that made Knicks fans believe. Why?
In the sports world when you have someone come from out of nowhere and enjoy success it excites fans mostly because the fans can dream about doing it themselves. What kid wouldn't love to take Kobe to school on the court? Jeremy Lin never went to school at a basketball powerhouse. He was a HArvard boy with enough talent to barely get a look in the NBA. Then, all of a sudden, like Robert Redford in The Natural, he is hitting game winning shots and putting up rookie numbers that haven't been seen in a long time. With this type of success you will have people looking to cash in, especially on the secondary market.
Enter the eBay Lin craze. Enter the Lin craze in general. In a society fueled by the need to have the latest and greatest, people are running out and buying everything Jeremy Lin. Jeremy Lin is the new iPhone of the NBA. Everyone has to have his jersey. People want his autograph. People need to follow him on Twitter (his account by the way now has 217,195 followers as of 2:27 PM on Feb. 13th). People want to feel a part of "IT", whatever "IT" is. Right now, Jeremy Lin is "it" because he has helped turn around the Knicks season which was looking like it was going to be a huge disappointment. In a city with over 8 million people and a metro area of about 14 million, being the next big thing is huge. We have all seen the Facebook and Twitter posts of our friends who are suddenly interested in Knicks basketball again, even if the last Knick they could name was Patrick Ewing.
Jeremy Lin is bringing the swagger back to New York, especially on the heels of the New York Giants winning the Super Bowl. New York is becoming cool again in sports. Even the New York Rangers are atop the NHL standings and the Yankees are poised for another playoff run. New York has had it's share of winners over the years but the Knicks haven't had much success since Patrick Ewing left and now, with the help of a scrawny Harvard kid, the Knicks are relevant again in a way that might even make Patrick jealous.
So, will the Jeremy Lin market crash? In a conversation on Twitter with Beckett editor, Chris Olds, who clearly has a pulse on the card market, he believes there is a chance for the Lin market, at least the Lin card market to sustain these prices if people start putting them away and not flooding the market with it. He is right. There are limited numbers of these cards since card companies, like Panini, are not overproducing cards like they did in the 1980's and 1990's. If people are putting the Lin's away into their personal collections and the demand remains high then there won't be a crash. My personal belief is that greed will win out and these cards will keep on getting posted, especially if the Knicks make the playoffs and Jeremy Lin continues this absurd level of playing. People will always look to cash in. It's human nature. There will be a few who will keep their Jeremy Lin rookie cards, if I had one I might take advantage of the craze and post it up for sale but if I had doubles I would keep one for my own collection.
Bottom line, if you think the Jeremy Lin craze is at a fever pitch now, just wait if the Knicks get to the NBA Finals and this kid is still playing at this level. You ain't seen nothing yet.
Thursday, February 9, 2012
Some of this and a little of that
-Mets GM Sandy Alderson is now on Twitter and opened his account with a bit of a joke. It read, "Getting ready for Spring Training-Driving to FL but haven't left yet. Big fundraiser tonight for gas money. Also exploring PAC contribution." Pretty funny guy. Although this account isn't verified by Twitter just yet the Mets organization confirmed that it is Sandy's account. However, given the Mets propensity for misdiagnosing everything from injuries to free agent contracts I wouldn't hold my breath just yet.
-The New York Knicks have their Tim Tebow. Jeremy Lin has exploded in New York, and around the league. He has scored 25, 28, and 23 points in his last three games and has almost single handedly made Knicks fans forget that Carmelo Anthony and Amar'e Stoudemire are out with injury or, as in Stoudemire's case, out grieving a lost brother. It also helped that Lin won the game against Utah on February 6th. Yeah, the Knicks might have found an answer in Lin or they may have created more questions in the long run. Personally, I'll wait and see what happens when Carmelo and Amar'e come back and see how the kid handles the point guard position then. I also wonder if the monetary commitment to Baron Davis will make a difference in Lin's playing time when Davis comes back from injury. For now, it's hard not to like the kid. He went to Harvard and has come from out of nowhere. Of course he is going to be hyped. Time will tell if the kid is as good as these three games says he is. I, however, have liked what I have seen in the bits and pieces that I can stand to watch pro basketball. Here you can see Maurice Evans avoid being posterized by Lin as he goes in for a dynamic dunk. Nice defense Evans.
-The Yankees signed Russell Branyan to a minor league contract yesterday. Branyan is getting up there in age, he is 36 years old, and his production suffered mightily last season. Between the Los Angeles Angels of Anaheim (can you please change your name back to the California Angels because this name sucks) and Arizona Diamondbacks he hit .197 with 5 homers and 14 RBI's. He has, however, hit two of the longest home runs ever at the new Yankee Stadium, the longest of which travelled 451 feet. He isn't that far removed from hitting 31 homers, which he did in Seattle in 2009 so it might be worth a shot. Branyan will either hit the ball deep or strike out so there won't be much suspense if he makes the team. Joining Branyan with the hopes of keeping their Major League dreams alive are DeWayne Wise (famous for his catch that saved Mark Buerhle's no-hitter), Manny Delcarmen, Hideki Okajima, and Bill Hall.
-Dennis "Oil Can" Boyd admits he was under the influence of cocaine when he pitched sometimes. Somehow, even as a kid, I had that feeling. He blames racism for his not getting another chance like Dwight Gooden, Darryl Strawberry, and Steve Howe. He claims that he was a loud and proud black man and he was discriminated against because of this. My question is, when was this guy not on cocaine? He says he pitched "two-thirds" of his games under the influence but he doesn't say when he actually quit the drug, if he did at all. That could have a lot to do with it. If he was stil using and wasn't performing why would ANY team give him a shot? At least in Gooden and Strawberry and Howe's cases, these men had stopped using, had entered treatment facilities and are, in Gooden and Strawberry's case, still dealing with the struggle to stay clean. Boyd needs to stop pointing the finger at a racist MLB and start looking in the mirror. He has nobody to blame but himself.
-Here is an interesting tidbit, Mike Napoli heads into arbitration as being one of only 4 catchers to average 20 homers a season in his first six seasons. The others? Oh, just Mike Piazza, Roy Campanella, and Johnny Bench. Amazing.
-The Yankees and Pirates are talking about a deal for AJ Burnett. According to Buster Olney, the Yankees are asking for Garrett Jones and the Pirates aren't interested in dealing him. I don't know if a deal will happen, in fact I'd be surprised. The Pirates will most likely ask the Yankees to eat most, if not all, of Burnett's contract while not giving up any decent players or prospects. Jones is a nice player who would fit in nicely in the OF/1B/DH rotation and provide some pop.
-After watching the New York Rangers lose a game-tying goal in the closing seconds of their game against the Devils thanks to a blown call by the referee, I think it is time the NHL adopt a review policy like that of the NFL. Simply reviewing that potentially-game altering play would have shown there was no penalty and that goal should have counted, thereby awarding each team one point. Instead, the game was over and the Devils got two points all because a referee got a call wrong. In the last minute of every game if there is a goal it should be reviewed, regardless if there is a penalty or not on the play. If no penalty is seen then the goal should count. Period. Just my two cents.
-
-The New York Knicks have their Tim Tebow. Jeremy Lin has exploded in New York, and around the league. He has scored 25, 28, and 23 points in his last three games and has almost single handedly made Knicks fans forget that Carmelo Anthony and Amar'e Stoudemire are out with injury or, as in Stoudemire's case, out grieving a lost brother. It also helped that Lin won the game against Utah on February 6th. Yeah, the Knicks might have found an answer in Lin or they may have created more questions in the long run. Personally, I'll wait and see what happens when Carmelo and Amar'e come back and see how the kid handles the point guard position then. I also wonder if the monetary commitment to Baron Davis will make a difference in Lin's playing time when Davis comes back from injury. For now, it's hard not to like the kid. He went to Harvard and has come from out of nowhere. Of course he is going to be hyped. Time will tell if the kid is as good as these three games says he is. I, however, have liked what I have seen in the bits and pieces that I can stand to watch pro basketball. Here you can see Maurice Evans avoid being posterized by Lin as he goes in for a dynamic dunk. Nice defense Evans.
-The Yankees signed Russell Branyan to a minor league contract yesterday. Branyan is getting up there in age, he is 36 years old, and his production suffered mightily last season. Between the Los Angeles Angels of Anaheim (can you please change your name back to the California Angels because this name sucks) and Arizona Diamondbacks he hit .197 with 5 homers and 14 RBI's. He has, however, hit two of the longest home runs ever at the new Yankee Stadium, the longest of which travelled 451 feet. He isn't that far removed from hitting 31 homers, which he did in Seattle in 2009 so it might be worth a shot. Branyan will either hit the ball deep or strike out so there won't be much suspense if he makes the team. Joining Branyan with the hopes of keeping their Major League dreams alive are DeWayne Wise (famous for his catch that saved Mark Buerhle's no-hitter), Manny Delcarmen, Hideki Okajima, and Bill Hall.
-Dennis "Oil Can" Boyd admits he was under the influence of cocaine when he pitched sometimes. Somehow, even as a kid, I had that feeling. He blames racism for his not getting another chance like Dwight Gooden, Darryl Strawberry, and Steve Howe. He claims that he was a loud and proud black man and he was discriminated against because of this. My question is, when was this guy not on cocaine? He says he pitched "two-thirds" of his games under the influence but he doesn't say when he actually quit the drug, if he did at all. That could have a lot to do with it. If he was stil using and wasn't performing why would ANY team give him a shot? At least in Gooden and Strawberry and Howe's cases, these men had stopped using, had entered treatment facilities and are, in Gooden and Strawberry's case, still dealing with the struggle to stay clean. Boyd needs to stop pointing the finger at a racist MLB and start looking in the mirror. He has nobody to blame but himself.
-Here is an interesting tidbit, Mike Napoli heads into arbitration as being one of only 4 catchers to average 20 homers a season in his first six seasons. The others? Oh, just Mike Piazza, Roy Campanella, and Johnny Bench. Amazing.
-The Yankees and Pirates are talking about a deal for AJ Burnett. According to Buster Olney, the Yankees are asking for Garrett Jones and the Pirates aren't interested in dealing him. I don't know if a deal will happen, in fact I'd be surprised. The Pirates will most likely ask the Yankees to eat most, if not all, of Burnett's contract while not giving up any decent players or prospects. Jones is a nice player who would fit in nicely in the OF/1B/DH rotation and provide some pop.
-After watching the New York Rangers lose a game-tying goal in the closing seconds of their game against the Devils thanks to a blown call by the referee, I think it is time the NHL adopt a review policy like that of the NFL. Simply reviewing that potentially-game altering play would have shown there was no penalty and that goal should have counted, thereby awarding each team one point. Instead, the game was over and the Devils got two points all because a referee got a call wrong. In the last minute of every game if there is a goal it should be reviewed, regardless if there is a penalty or not on the play. If no penalty is seen then the goal should count. Period. Just my two cents.
-
Tuesday, February 7, 2012
Hall of Shame
Right before the Super Bowl, the NFL announced it's Hall of Fame class. Needless to say I was shocked at the omissions. I'm not saying that these guys didn't deserve a shot at the Hall of Fame, but some of the omissions have left me angry at the NFL and the way people are elected into the Hall of Fame.
Cris Carter is second all-time among receivers with 130 TD receptions. He is also one of eight players to have over 1,000 receptions. He has been eligible since 2008 and yet he still finds himself on the outside looking in. Carter led the league in receptions one year (1994) with 122. The following year, Carter tied his career high with another 122 receptions. He led the league in touchdown catches three times. He was an 8x Pro Bowler to boot. There is no way Cortez Kennedy is more valuable than Cris Carter.
Let's talk about Cortez Kennedy. He was elected to the Pro Bowl 8 times, never led the league in a single category, and recorded double digit sacks just once, 14 in 1992. He was a good player but not Hall of Fame worthy in my opinion. His 568 tackles and 58 career sacks don't come close to the numbers that other, more deserving players put up. One of those players was Charles Haley.
Charles Haley did get elected to the Pro bowl as many times as Cortez Kennedy. Haley was only elected 5 times. However, Haley ended his NFL career with 100.5 sacks. More importantly, Haley led the 49ers defense to Super Bowls and then helped Dallas do the same. He was the heart of several Championship defenses and a terror to opposing quarterbacks. I know he had more of an impact on the game than Cortez Kennedy did. I'm not trying to diminish what Kennedy did but Haley was the best on some of the best defenses in the game. That has to count for something.
How Bill Parcells is left off is beyond me. That is just ludicrous. He turned around a pathetic Giants team and brought 2 Super Bowl Championships to New York. Then he took New England from the depths and brought them to a Super Bowl. Then, he became the head coach of the Jets and turned that franchise around. Next, he took a struggling Dallas team and remade them into title contenders. He even almost rejuvenated a Dolphins franchise. Everywhere he has gone he has won. He deserves to be in the Hall of Fame, period.
Andre Reed was the number one receiving option on one of the most explosive offenses in football history and yet did not get elected. Tim Brown is another of the best receivers of his generation and yet did not get elected. Something is fishy about the way the NFL allows people to vote. Surely it wouldn't hurt if they made people make their ballots public like they do in baseball. I say they do it so people can explain how they voted.
Cris Carter is second all-time among receivers with 130 TD receptions. He is also one of eight players to have over 1,000 receptions. He has been eligible since 2008 and yet he still finds himself on the outside looking in. Carter led the league in receptions one year (1994) with 122. The following year, Carter tied his career high with another 122 receptions. He led the league in touchdown catches three times. He was an 8x Pro Bowler to boot. There is no way Cortez Kennedy is more valuable than Cris Carter.
Let's talk about Cortez Kennedy. He was elected to the Pro Bowl 8 times, never led the league in a single category, and recorded double digit sacks just once, 14 in 1992. He was a good player but not Hall of Fame worthy in my opinion. His 568 tackles and 58 career sacks don't come close to the numbers that other, more deserving players put up. One of those players was Charles Haley.
Charles Haley did get elected to the Pro bowl as many times as Cortez Kennedy. Haley was only elected 5 times. However, Haley ended his NFL career with 100.5 sacks. More importantly, Haley led the 49ers defense to Super Bowls and then helped Dallas do the same. He was the heart of several Championship defenses and a terror to opposing quarterbacks. I know he had more of an impact on the game than Cortez Kennedy did. I'm not trying to diminish what Kennedy did but Haley was the best on some of the best defenses in the game. That has to count for something.
How Bill Parcells is left off is beyond me. That is just ludicrous. He turned around a pathetic Giants team and brought 2 Super Bowl Championships to New York. Then he took New England from the depths and brought them to a Super Bowl. Then, he became the head coach of the Jets and turned that franchise around. Next, he took a struggling Dallas team and remade them into title contenders. He even almost rejuvenated a Dolphins franchise. Everywhere he has gone he has won. He deserves to be in the Hall of Fame, period.
Andre Reed was the number one receiving option on one of the most explosive offenses in football history and yet did not get elected. Tim Brown is another of the best receivers of his generation and yet did not get elected. Something is fishy about the way the NFL allows people to vote. Surely it wouldn't hurt if they made people make their ballots public like they do in baseball. I say they do it so people can explain how they voted.
Super Bowl Hangover? Not in New York
The New York Football Giants are Super Bowl Champions. The confetti has been cleaned up and the champagne has been drunk but there is no hangover in New York. The New York Giants defeated Tom Brady and the Patriots for the second time in 4 years in the sports biggest game and New York football has taken center-stage once again. Amazingly, it had nothing to do with Rex Ryan who must be on Zoloft by now after watching the team that shares a stadium with the Jets beat the team that reigns in their division. It happens sometimes, Rex. In all seriousness, that was the last shot I'm taking at Rex Ryan or the Jets in this post because it isn't about the Jets right now. It is about the New York Giants. They are the Champions of football once again. I never thought this team had a shot at the beginning of the year. Never. I don't think there was a Giants fan out there who thought the team would be Super Bowl bound after they were at 7-7 after losing to the Washington Redskins. I have seen every Giants Super Bowl and they all seem to have one moment (ok, not the Ravens Super Bowl debacle but all the wins do) that makes the game a classic. In 1986 there was Phil McConkey with the catch and Phil Simms setting the all-time Super Bowl completion percentage. In 1990 there was Mark Ingram's catch and Scott Norwood's wide right. Hell, even in 2000 Ron Dixon had the kickoff return for a TD. In 2007, there was David Tyree catching the ball against his helmet after Eli Manning escapes a sure sack. Then, there was the Plaxico Burress TD catch in the corner of the endzone. There was the defeat of a previously undefeated team and the thrill of victory. Then, this year, there was Mario Manningham's catch that led to the Giants game-winning "reluctant touchdown" by Ahmad Bradshaw. There was Eli Manning leading his team down the field for one more 4th quarter comeback in a season full of them. There was Chase Blackburn, the guy who started the year as a substitute teacher before being signed right before the Giants-Packers game in early December, getting a timely interception against Tom Brady and Rob Gronkowski, a tight end coming off of one of the best single seasons ever at his position.
As the Giants bring the Lombardi Trophy to the New York/New Jersey area, it is fitting to think about the history that the New York Giants have had in this game. No, they don't own the record for most Super Bowl victories. But, there is something special about Big Blue. Something that no other team can claim. The New York Giants were where some of the game's greatest coaches got their start, whether as head coach or assistant. A quick mental check reveals Vince Lombardi, Tom Landry, Bill Parcells, Bill Belichick, and Tom Coughlin all began their coaching careers with Big Blue. It just seems fitting that the Lombardi Trophy now resides in New York.
It might be years before Giants fans stop talking about this past Super Bowl. The memories of the last Giants Super Bowl were still fresh in every Giants mind as they prepared for a rematch. I hope, as a Giants fan, that I don't have to wait more than two years for another Super Bowl but I know I will have this one to keep me warm for many winters to come if need be. Especially when the embers of the Giants Super Bowl XLII win still smolders all these years later. Thank you Big Blue.
As the Giants bring the Lombardi Trophy to the New York/New Jersey area, it is fitting to think about the history that the New York Giants have had in this game. No, they don't own the record for most Super Bowl victories. But, there is something special about Big Blue. Something that no other team can claim. The New York Giants were where some of the game's greatest coaches got their start, whether as head coach or assistant. A quick mental check reveals Vince Lombardi, Tom Landry, Bill Parcells, Bill Belichick, and Tom Coughlin all began their coaching careers with Big Blue. It just seems fitting that the Lombardi Trophy now resides in New York.
It might be years before Giants fans stop talking about this past Super Bowl. The memories of the last Giants Super Bowl were still fresh in every Giants mind as they prepared for a rematch. I hope, as a Giants fan, that I don't have to wait more than two years for another Super Bowl but I know I will have this one to keep me warm for many winters to come if need be. Especially when the embers of the Giants Super Bowl XLII win still smolders all these years later. Thank you Big Blue.
Wednesday, February 1, 2012
Sandy and the Mets
The New york Mets are in a bit of a bind. They have financial problems that threaten the entire organization, all stemming from the Wilpon's decision to invest in Bernie Madoff's ponzi scheme. Omar Minaya and Jerry Manuel were fired two seasons ago and now the Mets are run by Sandy Alderson, who some believe fostered sabermetrics in the baseball world and gave birth to Billy Beane, the star of Moneyball. Well, here in reality, I see Sandy Alderson, not as the father of sabermatricians everywhere but rather a shrewd evaluator of baseball talent. Here is a look at some of the players Alderson drafted during his tenure as general manager of the Oakland Athletics:
1984: Drafted Mark McGwire in the first round with the 10th overall pick. McGwire, with, or without the help of performance enhancers, would go on to become one of the greatest sluggers in the game. Oh, and he won the Rookie of the Year Award.
1985: Drafted Walt Weiss with the 11th overall pick in the first round. Weiss would win the Rookie of the Year award as well and would go on to become a serviceable player for years and helped lead the A's to a World Series title.
1986: Alderson drafted two players who would go on to have very productive careers, albeit for other teams. He drafted Kevin Tapani in the second round and Rod Beck in the 13th. Tapani would be a very good middle of the rotation starter for the Twins and Rod Beck would be a dominant closer for the Giants in the mid-1990's.
1987: This draft was a little lackluster. Scott Brosius, who went on to be traded for Kenny Rogers, would go on to help the Yankees win a World Series or two, or three.
1988: Nobody big drafted here. Just a few serviceable players like Darren Lewis and Joe Grahe.
1989: Another kind of blah year with Matt Mieske, Kurt Abbott, Craig Paquette, and Dana Allison types. Good enough to make the majors, maybe even have a very good year or two but not good enough to keep it up.
1990: Everyone who grew up collecting baseball cards in the 1990's remembers the name Todd Van Poppel. He was the top pitching prospect in all of baseball at one point but never came close to living up to expectations, mostly due to injury. Other serviceable Major Leaguers drafted that year include Tanyon Sturtze, Kirk Dressendorfer, Ernie Young, and Izzy Molina.
1991: Not a very good draft.
1992: Jason Giambi was picked in the 2nd round. He would only go on to win an MVP in an A's uniform before bolting for more money in the Bronx.
1993: Scott Spiezio was taken in the 6th round. He helped the Angels win the World Series in 2002.
1994: Ben Grieve, who would go on to win yet another Rookie of the Year Award for the A's was drafted here. He had a nice career but flamed out early on. I wouldn't mind having had Grieve's career in the Majors. Not for one second. Tim Hudson was also drafted but did not sign.
1995: Mark Bellhorn was drafted in the 2nd round. Bellhorn was a decent enough middle infielder. Other notables include Jeff DaVanon and David Newhan.
1996: Eric Chavez highlights this class. Chavez was one of the best third basemen in the entire Major Leagues. Too bad injuries sapped him of all of his Hall of Fame potential.
1997: Drafted Tim Hudson again in the 6th round and inked him to a contract this time. He only won 20 games and helped take the "Moneyball" A's to the playoffs. He was an ace and is still pitching very well for Atlanta.
1998: Mark Mulder, one of the three aces that had nothing to do with the success of the Oakland Athletics "Moneyball" years was taken with the 2nd overall pick. Mulder won 20 games but his career was shortened due to injury. Gerald Laird, and Eric Byrnes are the other notables from this draft class.
Then, the torch was passed to Billy Beane who profited more than any other general manager from his predecessors draft classes. Yes, Beane did draft Barry Zito to round out the big three but it was Alderson that laid the groundwork. It was Alderson who signed Miguel Tejada, drafted Eric Chavez, and Jason Giambi. Yes, none of those guys stayed but it was also their departures that paved the way for new draft picks like Nick Swisher, for example, who was taken with the compensation pick after the A's lost Giambi. Sandy Alderson made the A's into what Billy Beane got credit for. There is no doubt in my mind.
Since taking the reigns from Omar Minaya and the clueless Mets ownership that allowed Minaya to ink the likes of Jason Bay, Luis Castillo, and Oliver Perez to name a few, Alderson has set about rebuilding the Mets team. Granted, he doesn't have the resources that Minaya enjoyed but he has a plan and a keen eye for baseball talent that Minaya never had. Let's not forget that this is the same Omar Minaya that traded Cliff Lee, Grady Sizemore, and Brandon Phillips to the Indians for Bartolo Colon and Tim Drew when he was GM of the Expos. Gee, I wonder if the Expos, who turned into the Nationals, would have liked to have a middle of the field that included Brandon Phillips at second, Grady in center, and Cliff Lee on the mound? Colon did go 10-4 with a 3.31 ERA for the Expos but he was traded to the White Sox for...get this...Rocky Biddle, Orlando Hernandez, and Jeff Liefer! Great job Minaya. You turned 3 players who made the All-Star team later on for basically a washed up El Duque, a middling middle reliever in Biddle, and a guy who barely made the Majors in Liefer. Congrats! Oh, and those playoff hopes that Minaya saw and dealt the future for? Well, the Expos finished 12 games out of the playoffs. So, ummm, yeah. It's hard taking over for stupidity. Well, I'll give him a bit of a pass because he did give up bopkus for a couple of good seasons of Johan Santana.
The Mets farm system hasn't produced a star since David Wright debuted in 2004. Before that it was Jose Reyes. The Mets haven't been known for their farm system in years. It has been neglected and abused over the years. Look at the "Top Prospects" that have come forth: Paul Wilson, Bill Pulsipher, Jason Isringhausen, Carlos Gomez, Fernando Martinez, Alex Escobar...the list goes on. These were top prospects that were either rushed to the majors, suffered major injuries, or saw success on other teams, or all three. The Mets and farm system do NOT go together. Don't mention Ike Davis to me just yet, he has a lot to prove, including staying healthy. I have written about the Mets farm abuse before, you can look in the archives for those stories. This is nothing new. Enter Sandy Alderson.
Alderson has been the Mets GM for two seasons now. Really, he has one full season under his belt as Mets GM, having taken over in October of 2010. He has had one draft with the Mets. One. Yet, Mets fans are already ready to fire him. He let Jose Reyes walk. He spent $10 million on middle relievers and bench players. He drafted Brandon Nimmo who never played high school baseball. The list of complaints, all of them unwarranted, goes on. Alderson has not even gotten his office set up yet at Citi Field and already Mets fans want him gone, afraid that he is trying to turn the Mets into Oakland East. Let's not forget that Alderson did build a World Series winner using a fairly big payroll in 1989. His teams also went to two other World Series'. The man knows baseball, period. He turned Carlos Beltran, who was not coming back to Queens, into a top pitching prospect in Zack Wheeler. The Giants got half of a season out of Beltran who went to St. Louis. Score one for Alderson.
Alderson fleeced San Francisco again when he sent Angel Pagan to the Giants in exchange for Andres Torres and Ramon Ramirez. Torres and Pagan are kind of interchangeable. Pagan had a bit of a stigma as a clubhouse distraction and getting a similar player and a middle reliever in exchange for him was a solid move. Within hours of that trade, Alderson inked Jon Rauch and Frank Francisco to contracts. Both are middle relievers. Both should be decent enough in Citi Field, even with the fences moved in, to get some decent prospects in return come July when every MLB team in the race is looking for bullpen upgrades. None of these moves made this offseason are for this year. They are stopgaps and plugs to bide time until Alderson's draft classes, and Matt Harvey, and some others are ready to help take the reigns of the future. Most of the veterans are pieces to be used in trades for prospects which will allow Mets ownership to breathe a little and regroup. The goal of the Mets is NOT to become the A's of the East. There is no way fans would pay to watch that and the Wilpon's are businessmen who are probably tired of losing money at this point. Having an empty new stadium is probably not on their list of things they want.
Mets fans need to calm down and stop demanding Sandy Alderson's job already. He hasn't had a chance to execute his plan. Firing him now would only add years onto the Mets rebuilding plan and possibly destroy it. I'd have faith in a guy who found McGwire, Giambi, Tejada, Hudson, Mulder, and Chavez. Why wouldn't you?
1984: Drafted Mark McGwire in the first round with the 10th overall pick. McGwire, with, or without the help of performance enhancers, would go on to become one of the greatest sluggers in the game. Oh, and he won the Rookie of the Year Award.
1985: Drafted Walt Weiss with the 11th overall pick in the first round. Weiss would win the Rookie of the Year award as well and would go on to become a serviceable player for years and helped lead the A's to a World Series title.
1986: Alderson drafted two players who would go on to have very productive careers, albeit for other teams. He drafted Kevin Tapani in the second round and Rod Beck in the 13th. Tapani would be a very good middle of the rotation starter for the Twins and Rod Beck would be a dominant closer for the Giants in the mid-1990's.
1987: This draft was a little lackluster. Scott Brosius, who went on to be traded for Kenny Rogers, would go on to help the Yankees win a World Series or two, or three.
1988: Nobody big drafted here. Just a few serviceable players like Darren Lewis and Joe Grahe.
1989: Another kind of blah year with Matt Mieske, Kurt Abbott, Craig Paquette, and Dana Allison types. Good enough to make the majors, maybe even have a very good year or two but not good enough to keep it up.
1990: Everyone who grew up collecting baseball cards in the 1990's remembers the name Todd Van Poppel. He was the top pitching prospect in all of baseball at one point but never came close to living up to expectations, mostly due to injury. Other serviceable Major Leaguers drafted that year include Tanyon Sturtze, Kirk Dressendorfer, Ernie Young, and Izzy Molina.
1991: Not a very good draft.
1992: Jason Giambi was picked in the 2nd round. He would only go on to win an MVP in an A's uniform before bolting for more money in the Bronx.
1993: Scott Spiezio was taken in the 6th round. He helped the Angels win the World Series in 2002.
1994: Ben Grieve, who would go on to win yet another Rookie of the Year Award for the A's was drafted here. He had a nice career but flamed out early on. I wouldn't mind having had Grieve's career in the Majors. Not for one second. Tim Hudson was also drafted but did not sign.
1995: Mark Bellhorn was drafted in the 2nd round. Bellhorn was a decent enough middle infielder. Other notables include Jeff DaVanon and David Newhan.
1996: Eric Chavez highlights this class. Chavez was one of the best third basemen in the entire Major Leagues. Too bad injuries sapped him of all of his Hall of Fame potential.
1997: Drafted Tim Hudson again in the 6th round and inked him to a contract this time. He only won 20 games and helped take the "Moneyball" A's to the playoffs. He was an ace and is still pitching very well for Atlanta.
1998: Mark Mulder, one of the three aces that had nothing to do with the success of the Oakland Athletics "Moneyball" years was taken with the 2nd overall pick. Mulder won 20 games but his career was shortened due to injury. Gerald Laird, and Eric Byrnes are the other notables from this draft class.
Then, the torch was passed to Billy Beane who profited more than any other general manager from his predecessors draft classes. Yes, Beane did draft Barry Zito to round out the big three but it was Alderson that laid the groundwork. It was Alderson who signed Miguel Tejada, drafted Eric Chavez, and Jason Giambi. Yes, none of those guys stayed but it was also their departures that paved the way for new draft picks like Nick Swisher, for example, who was taken with the compensation pick after the A's lost Giambi. Sandy Alderson made the A's into what Billy Beane got credit for. There is no doubt in my mind.
Since taking the reigns from Omar Minaya and the clueless Mets ownership that allowed Minaya to ink the likes of Jason Bay, Luis Castillo, and Oliver Perez to name a few, Alderson has set about rebuilding the Mets team. Granted, he doesn't have the resources that Minaya enjoyed but he has a plan and a keen eye for baseball talent that Minaya never had. Let's not forget that this is the same Omar Minaya that traded Cliff Lee, Grady Sizemore, and Brandon Phillips to the Indians for Bartolo Colon and Tim Drew when he was GM of the Expos. Gee, I wonder if the Expos, who turned into the Nationals, would have liked to have a middle of the field that included Brandon Phillips at second, Grady in center, and Cliff Lee on the mound? Colon did go 10-4 with a 3.31 ERA for the Expos but he was traded to the White Sox for...get this...Rocky Biddle, Orlando Hernandez, and Jeff Liefer! Great job Minaya. You turned 3 players who made the All-Star team later on for basically a washed up El Duque, a middling middle reliever in Biddle, and a guy who barely made the Majors in Liefer. Congrats! Oh, and those playoff hopes that Minaya saw and dealt the future for? Well, the Expos finished 12 games out of the playoffs. So, ummm, yeah. It's hard taking over for stupidity. Well, I'll give him a bit of a pass because he did give up bopkus for a couple of good seasons of Johan Santana.
The Mets farm system hasn't produced a star since David Wright debuted in 2004. Before that it was Jose Reyes. The Mets haven't been known for their farm system in years. It has been neglected and abused over the years. Look at the "Top Prospects" that have come forth: Paul Wilson, Bill Pulsipher, Jason Isringhausen, Carlos Gomez, Fernando Martinez, Alex Escobar...the list goes on. These were top prospects that were either rushed to the majors, suffered major injuries, or saw success on other teams, or all three. The Mets and farm system do NOT go together. Don't mention Ike Davis to me just yet, he has a lot to prove, including staying healthy. I have written about the Mets farm abuse before, you can look in the archives for those stories. This is nothing new. Enter Sandy Alderson.
Alderson has been the Mets GM for two seasons now. Really, he has one full season under his belt as Mets GM, having taken over in October of 2010. He has had one draft with the Mets. One. Yet, Mets fans are already ready to fire him. He let Jose Reyes walk. He spent $10 million on middle relievers and bench players. He drafted Brandon Nimmo who never played high school baseball. The list of complaints, all of them unwarranted, goes on. Alderson has not even gotten his office set up yet at Citi Field and already Mets fans want him gone, afraid that he is trying to turn the Mets into Oakland East. Let's not forget that Alderson did build a World Series winner using a fairly big payroll in 1989. His teams also went to two other World Series'. The man knows baseball, period. He turned Carlos Beltran, who was not coming back to Queens, into a top pitching prospect in Zack Wheeler. The Giants got half of a season out of Beltran who went to St. Louis. Score one for Alderson.
Alderson fleeced San Francisco again when he sent Angel Pagan to the Giants in exchange for Andres Torres and Ramon Ramirez. Torres and Pagan are kind of interchangeable. Pagan had a bit of a stigma as a clubhouse distraction and getting a similar player and a middle reliever in exchange for him was a solid move. Within hours of that trade, Alderson inked Jon Rauch and Frank Francisco to contracts. Both are middle relievers. Both should be decent enough in Citi Field, even with the fences moved in, to get some decent prospects in return come July when every MLB team in the race is looking for bullpen upgrades. None of these moves made this offseason are for this year. They are stopgaps and plugs to bide time until Alderson's draft classes, and Matt Harvey, and some others are ready to help take the reigns of the future. Most of the veterans are pieces to be used in trades for prospects which will allow Mets ownership to breathe a little and regroup. The goal of the Mets is NOT to become the A's of the East. There is no way fans would pay to watch that and the Wilpon's are businessmen who are probably tired of losing money at this point. Having an empty new stadium is probably not on their list of things they want.
Mets fans need to calm down and stop demanding Sandy Alderson's job already. He hasn't had a chance to execute his plan. Firing him now would only add years onto the Mets rebuilding plan and possibly destroy it. I'd have faith in a guy who found McGwire, Giambi, Tejada, Hudson, Mulder, and Chavez. Why wouldn't you?
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)